How often
Supervision is a regular meeting, and appraisal is a yearly review
The two get confused because the same manager usually does both. Supervision is the regular conversation about how the work is going. Appraisal comes once a year, sets your objectives, and those objectives are then checked at each supervision.
Months of the year
Supervision, as Skills for Care recommends it
For experienced workers
Monthly or every six weeks, one to one and a half hours each time.
Supervision, the least NICE home care guidance allows
Home care workers
At least every 3 months, with an agreed written record given to you.
Your work observed on a visit
Often called a spot check
At least every 3 months, to find your strengths and what you could develop.
Appraisal
Once a year
At least once a year. It looks back over the year, includes what clients and families have said, and sets objectives for the next one.
New workers: Skills for Care’s example timetable has weekly supervision, and NICE asks for a new home care worker to be observed at work more than once during induction. Months are counted from your start date or your last appraisal.
Neither CQC nor the law sets a number of weeks. The frequencies above come from Skills for Care, the body that sets workforce standards for adult social care in England, and from NICE's guideline on home care. Your employer's supervision policy should say what you can expect, and Skills for Care's guide says staff should be told this when they start. If you are new to the work, expect more sessions at first, and expect to be observed at work more than once during your induction.
The observed visit is separate from supervision. Someone senior watches you on a real visit, and NICE asks that it is used to find your strengths and what you could develop. It feeds into your next supervision and your appraisal. There is more on how this fits into the rest of the job in carer resources.
Why employers must
Why a CQC-registered employer has to supervise and appraise you
If you work for a home care agency or care home registered with the Care Quality Commission, supervision and appraisal are a legal duty on your employer, not a favour.
Regulation 18 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014 says staff employed by a registered provider must "receive such appropriate support, training, professional development, supervision and appraisal as is necessary to enable them to carry out the duties they are employed to perform".
CQC's guidance on the regulation adds that staff should be supervised until they can show they are competent to work unsupervised, should have ongoing supervision to keep that competence up, and should receive regular appraisal from someone with the right skills and experience, with training needs identified and supported.
Because the duty sits with your employer, a session that keeps being cancelled is theirs to fix, and you are entitled to ask for a date.
The regulation covers people employed by a registered provider. A self-employed carer working directly for a family is not employed by one, so no one is required to supervise or appraise them. The last two sections of this page cover what to do instead.
In the session
What happens in a supervision session, and what to bring
Skills for Care describes supervision as doing three jobs at once: supporting you, managing the work and helping you learn. A good session gives time to all three, and Skills for Care asks managers to step back and let the worker lead the conversation.
Supervision record
One to one and a half hours, written up and shared with you
Opens with: how things are going and how you are feeling, then a look back at the actions agreed last time.
Support
How you are, and anything that is making the work hard.
- How work is going and how you are feeling
- Concerns, issues or challenges
- Health and safety
What you can bring
A visit that has stayed with you, or a client whose needs are changing.
Line management
Your workload, the standards expected and the paperwork.
- Actions from your last session
- Workload, tasks and targets
- Leave, sickness and flexible working requests
- New or changed policies
What you can bring
Rota problems, or anything stopping a visit going as the care plan says.
Learning and development
What you know, what you want to learn next and how.
- Your skills and knowledge, and any gaps
- Training, shadowing and buddying
- Progress on your appraisal objectives
What you can bring
One thing you want to learn, and how you would like to learn it.
Closes with: a summary, the actions each of you will take, and the date of the next session.
Supervision is two-way. You can put items on the agenda, and Skills for Care's guide asks supervisors to agree the agenda with you before the session. If something from a visit is worrying you, write it down when it happens, so you have the date and the detail when you sit down. NICE asks home care employers to give you an agreed written record of each session. Read it before you sign it, and ask for anything you disagree with to be noted.
Skills for Care is clear that supervision is not about one person exercising power over another. It can be used to manage performance, but it is equally a way for you to build skills, experience and confidence. Skills for Care's Effective supervision guide is written for managers, but reading its agenda before your first session shows you what to expect.
Example objectives
Example objectives for a care worker, written the SMART way
At appraisal you agree a small number of objectives for the year, and your supervisor checks them with you at each session. An objective that says what you will do, how you will know, and by when is far easier to show progress on than a wish.
- Specific
- Measurable
- Achievable
- Realistic
- Time-bound
A training goal
Written as: Do more training.
Complete a medication awareness refresher and have a senior watch me prompt medicines on two visits, using the course my employer already pays for, because three of my clients now have their medicines prompted, by the end of March.
A qualification
Written as: Get a qualification.
Enrol on the Level 2 Diploma in Care and finish the first two units, with one study afternoon a fortnight agreed on my rota, so I can apply for senior carer roles, before my next appraisal.
Your everyday practice
Written as: Write better care notes.
Write each visit note before I leave the house, in the client’s own words where I can, and ask my supervisor to read five of them, taking five minutes at the end of each visit, because the next carer relies on what I write, at my next supervision.
If you work for yourself
Written as: Get more feedback.
Ask each family I work for to write a review so I have three new ones, asking once the first month of visits has settled, because a family reads reviews before they message me, before my own yearly review in December.
Skills for Care suggests coming to an appraisal with three things that went well over the year and three that could have gone better. Those six lines are where your objectives come from. A good set mixes kinds: one about training or a qualification, one about your everyday practice, and one about where you want to be in a year, whether that is a senior role, a specialism such as dementia care, or more confidence with one task.
Keep each objective to something you control. "Get promoted" depends on your employer; "finish the units that a senior carer role asks for" depends on you. If a training goal needs a course to be renewed or a certificate refreshed, keeping your carer certifications up to date covers how often the common ones are refreshed and where to find the courses.
Care plan goals
Care plan goals belong to the client, and your objectives belong to you
A search for care plan goals and a form asking for your objectives can look like the same task. They are written by different people, for different reasons.
A care plan goal is something the person you support wants for their own life, written with them. NICE's home care guideline asks for the plan to start from the person's aspirations and priorities and what they can and want to do. "To make my own cup of tea again before my daughter visits at Easter" is a care plan goal. It is in the client's words, it belongs in their care plan, and it is reviewed with them and their family.
A staff objective is about your own work and development, and it belongs in your supervision record. The two link up when your objective helps the client reach theirs. Against the tea goal, a fair objective for the carer would be "follow the kitchen steps in the care plan on every morning visit, and note each week which steps Mrs P managed on her own". That is the way of working described in what a reablement care worker does, where stepping back is part of the job.
Never put a client's goal in your own objectives as though it were yours to meet. Whether they reach it depends on their health and their choices, and your appraisal should not rest on that.
Reflecting alone
Reflecting on your work when you are self-employed
When you leave an agency to work for yourself, supervision and appraisal stop. What they gave you, someone to talk to and a plan for your training, now has to come from you.
PrimeCarers is an introductory service, not a care agency, so nobody here supervises your visits, appraises your work or checks your training. You agree the work directly with each family, and keeping your practice under review is part of running your own business.
The habit that replaces supervision is a short reflective log, written after any visit that stays with you, good or bad. Skills for Care's guide includes a template with four headings. Here it is filled in for an ordinary morning that went less well than planned.
Reflective log
Tuesday 10 November
Describe what happened
What happened? When and where?
Morning visit to Mr D. He said no to his shower and got upset when I suggested it a second time. I helped him wash at the sink instead and wrote it in his notes.
Reflect on the experience
How did you behave? How did it make you feel?
I pushed because his care plan says a shower on Tuesdays and I was running late. I felt flustered, and worried his daughter would think I had skipped it.
Think about the experience
What guidance influenced your actions? How did the person experience it?
He has the right to refuse, and the Mental Capacity Act starts from the assumption that he can decide for himself. To him I was probably someone in a hurry telling him what to do.
Prepare for next time
What would you do differently? What learning do you need?
Ask him the day before which morning suits him, and tell his daughter the plan. Read up on consent and refusal, and ask her what his routine used to be.
A few lines under each heading is enough. Write it the same day, keep it somewhere private and leave out details another person would not need, such as the client's full name or address. Read your logs back every few months and look for the same thing coming up twice: that is where your next training goal comes from.
Supervision also looked after you. Nobody now notices when you are tired or carrying a hard visit home, so build that in too: looking after yourself as a paid carer covers setting limits on your week and where to get support after a hard visit.
Your own review
Your own yearly review: a CPD log, families' feedback and other carers
An appraisal is a look back over the year and a plan for the next one. You can do both for yourself in about an hour, as long as you have kept a record to look back at.
A CPD log (continuing professional development) is a running list of what you learned and when. Courses count, and so does reading, shadowing a nurse or therapist who shows you something for one client, or a conversation with other carers that changed how you work. The column that matters most is the last one: what you do differently because of it.
- 14 JanMedication awareness refresher, onlineTime: 3 hoursI now write the time and what was taken every time I prompt.
- 22 AprWatched the occupational therapist show Mrs P’s family and me how to use her perching stoolTime: 1 hourHer kitchen routine is written into the care plan, and I follow it step by step.
- 10 JunLocal personal assistant network meetingTime: 1.5 hoursStarted agreeing with each family where the visit notes are kept.
- 18 SepMoving and handling refresher, in personTime: 1 dayChanged how I help Mr D from bed to chair, and told his daughter why.
- 10 NovReflective log after a refused shower (above)Time: 30 minutesShower days are now agreed with Mr D the day before.
NICE asks home care employers to include feedback from the people they support and their families in each worker's yearly appraisal. Working for yourself, that feedback comes straight to you. Reviews from families who book you through PrimeCarers appear on your profile, and they belong in your yearly review alongside anything a family has said to you or written in the care diary.
Once a year, set aside an hour with your reflective logs, your CPD log and your reviews. Write down three things that went well and three that could have gone better, then turn them into two or three objectives in the shape shown earlier on this page. Keep the certificates with the log entries, since a family may ask to see them at interview.
The part of supervision that is hardest to replace is another experienced person to talk to. Skills for Care's support page for personal assistants points to personal assistant networks, support groups and forums where people doing the same work share what they know, and suggests starting one if there is none near you. A training course is also a good place to meet other carers. Agree with one or two of them to talk through a hard week now and then, keeping clients anonymous, and you have something close to the supportive side of supervision.
Questions
Questions care workers ask about supervision and appraisal
For staff employed by a CQC-registered provider, yes. Regulation 18 of the 2014 regulations requires appropriate supervision and appraisal. CQC cannot prosecute for a breach of this regulation, but it can take regulatory action against the provider. No law requires supervision for a self-employed carer working directly for a family.
Skills for Care's guide says the person who cannot make a session is responsible for rearranging it, ideally within a week of the original date. Ask your manager in writing for the next date and keep a copy. If sessions still do not happen, raise it with your registered manager, since the duty to supervise sits with the provider.
Yes. Skills for Care's guide suggests phone, chat, email and video calls as ways to keep in touch with home care workers, particularly for catching up between formal sessions. Your formal sessions should still be planned in advance and written up.
You should. NICE's home care guideline asks employers to give the worker an agreed written record of each supervision. If you are not offered one, ask for it, and ask for anything you disagree with to be noted in the record.
Skills for Care suggests allowing one to one and a half hours for a formal session, so there is time to talk things through and reflect. A short informal catch-up between sessions is also supervision, and its guide says those should be noted too.
No. PrimeCarers is an introductory service, not a care agency, so it does not supervise visits, appraise carers or check their training or qualifications. Training a carer lists on their profile is their own account, for a family to ask about at interview.
