Protein and muscle
Why older muscles need more protein than the adult guideline
Muscle is lost slowly through later life, and the ageing body makes less use of the protein it eats, so a parent who seems weaker may need more protein than they did when they were younger.
Loss of muscle mass and strength in later life is called sarcopenia. A healthcare fact sheet from the Malnutrition Pathway, a UK guide written by dietitians, GPs, nurses and pharmacists, describes muscle mass falling by around 30% to 50% between the ages of 40 and 80. Too little food, too little activity and illness all speed it up, and it makes falls, slow recovery from illness and needing more help at home more likely.
The UK reference amount of protein for adults is 0.75g for each kilogram of body weight a day, according to the British Dietetic Association. European expert groups, summarised in the Malnutrition Pathway fact sheet on protein, put healthy older adults at 1.0g to 1.2g per kilogram, and higher with a long-term condition or after an illness, because the ageing body does not use protein as well. For a woman of 55kg (about 8 stone 9 pounds) the difference looks like this.
- UK reference for all adults0.75g per kgabout 41g
- Healthy older adult1.0 to 1.2g per kg55 to 66g
- Older adult with an illness1.2 to 1.5g per kg66 to 83g
British Dietetic Association (0.75g per kg for adults who do not exercise); Malnutrition Pathway protein fact sheet, from the ESPEN expert group and PROT-AGE study group recommendations. A dietitian can work out the right amount for one person.
The same fact sheet says older muscles do best with 25g to 30g of good-quality protein at each meal, rather than most of the day's protein in one sitting. Meat, fish, eggs, milk, yoghurt and cheese are the good-quality sources it names; beans, lentils, nuts and soya count too, especially in combination.
Weight loss first
If they have lost weight without trying, the GP comes before the shop
Weight loss in later life can come from a treatable cause, such as a medicine, a sore mouth, low mood or an illness that has not been found yet. A protein powder can hide it for a while without treating it.
The NHS says that losing 5% to 10% or more of body weight over 3 to 6 months is one of the main signs of malnutrition, and to see a GP if someone has lost a lot of weight without meaning to. NICE asks GP surgeries to screen for malnutrition when there is a concern such as weight loss, loose clothes, poor appetite or wasted muscles. The screen most commonly used in the UK, according to BAPEN, the nutrition society that wrote it, is the Malnutrition Universal Screening Tool, known as MUST.
MUST adds up three scores: body mass index, the weight lost in the last 3 to 6 months, and whether an acute illness has stopped someone eating for more than 5 days. The total puts a person at low, medium or high risk, and that decides what the GP does next. If you know roughly what your parent weighed a few months ago, you can see where the weight loss part falls.
How much weight has gone without trying?
Use their usual weight from 3 to 6 months ago, from the GP record, a hospital letter or your own scales.
Enter both weights to see where the loss sits.
If the answer points to the GP, take the figures with you, and a few days of notes on what they ate. Our guide to what happens when an older person does not eat enough explains why it is worth acting early.
Protein from food
Three small meals can reach the protein older muscles need
Dietitians start with food, because food brings energy, vitamins and fibre along with the protein. With a smaller appetite, the aim is to make each mouthful carry more, so the plate does not have to get bigger.
NICE's guideline on nutrition support counts fortified food, extra snacks and changed meal patterns as nutrition support, alongside nutrition drinks, and the UK malnutrition pathway for GPs starts with advice on food. In practice that means a protein food at each meal, a milky pudding or yoghurt between meals, and fortified milk in place of ordinary milk. Fortified milk is the easiest change: whisk 5 tablespoons of dried skimmed milk powder into a pint of full fat milk, mixing it to a paste with a splash first. A University Hospitals Sussex leaflet gives the pint 41g of protein against 19g for the milk on its own, and it tastes like milk, so it can go into tea, porridge, custard, mashed potato and milky drinks without anyone noticing.
Three small meals that each reach 25 to 30g of protein, with no powder
- Food added or swapped
- Fortified milk
- 25 to 30g, the amount per meal
- The meal without the additions
Breakfast
about 25g- 150ml fortified milk in the porridge (10.8g)
- One egg, boiled or scrambled (7.1g)
- A small pot of whole plain yoghurt (125g) (7.1g)
Without the additions (porridge made with ordinary whole milk, and a cup of tea): about 5g.
Lunch
about 29g- Cheese on toast (45g cheddar) (11.4g)
- Baked beans on the side (135g) (6.8g)
- Rice pudding for afters (200g) (10.4g)
Without the additions (cheese on toast on its own): about 11g.
Tea
about 29g- Two eggs, scrambled (14.2g)
- A milky drink made with 200ml fortified milk (14.4g)
Without the additions (two scrambled eggs with ordinary milk to drink): about 21g.
None of these meals is large. Each one adds one or two things to what an older person might already eat, and each reaches the 25g to 30g that the Malnutrition Pathway gives for one sitting. Skimmed milk powder is, in effect, a protein powder made from milk, and NHS dietetic leaflets use it this way. The fuller picture of a balanced day, including vitamin D and drinks, is in nutrition and hydration for the elderly.
Powder or nutrition drink
A shop protein powder, a shop nutrition drink and a prescribed drink are different things
They sit next to each other on the shelf, but they are made for different people. The difference that matters for a parent who is losing weight is energy: someone who is not eating enough needs calories as well as protein, and NICE asks for nutrition support to give both.
A tub of protein powder
Whey, soya or pea, from a supermarket or online
A shop nutrition drink or powder
Ready to drink, or a powder to mix with milk, from a supermarket or pharmacy
A prescribed nutrition drink
Called oral nutritional supplements, or ONS
What it is
A protein concentrate sold mainly for sport and the gym. You stir a scoop into a drink or food.
A nutrition drink or powder of the kind the NHS prescribes, bought without a prescription.
A drink, or sometimes a pudding or powder, prescribed by the GP or a dietitian after a malnutrition screen.
What it adds
Mainly protein. It is not made to give the mix of energy, vitamins and minerals that NICE asks nutrition support to contain, so read the label.
Energy and protein together, with vitamins and minerals. A standard powdered drink made with milk gives about 16 to 18g of protein a serving.
Energy, protein, vitamins and minerals in a measured amount. A standard bottle gives about 300 calories and 12g of protein; high protein versions give more.
Who decides
You do. Nobody checks whether it suits your parent.
You do. UK malnutrition guidance suggests them for people at medium risk on the GP's screen.
The GP or dietitian, usually for people at high risk on the MUST screen.
Who checks it is working
None, unless you take it to the GP or pharmacist.
Ask the GP to recheck weight after one to three months.
At least monthly, and stopped once your parent is eating normally again.
When it fits
Someone who is eating enough overall, has no kidney disease, and finds it easier to stir a scoop into porridge or a drink than to eat more food.
Someone with a smaller appetite who is losing a little weight, once the GP knows about it.
Someone who has lost a lot of weight, is very thin, or is unwell and cannot eat enough food.
A tub of protein powder
Whey, soya or pea, from a supermarket or online
- What it is
- A protein concentrate sold mainly for sport and the gym. You stir a scoop into a drink or food.
- What it adds
- Mainly protein. It is not made to give the mix of energy, vitamins and minerals that NICE asks nutrition support to contain, so read the label.
- Who decides
- You do. Nobody checks whether it suits your parent.
- Who checks it is working
- None, unless you take it to the GP or pharmacist.
- When it fits
- Someone who is eating enough overall, has no kidney disease, and finds it easier to stir a scoop into porridge or a drink than to eat more food.
A shop nutrition drink or powder
Ready to drink, or a powder to mix with milk, from a supermarket or pharmacy
- What it is
- A nutrition drink or powder of the kind the NHS prescribes, bought without a prescription.
- What it adds
- Energy and protein together, with vitamins and minerals. A standard powdered drink made with milk gives about 16 to 18g of protein a serving.
- Who decides
- You do. UK malnutrition guidance suggests them for people at medium risk on the GP's screen.
- Who checks it is working
- Ask the GP to recheck weight after one to three months.
- When it fits
- Someone with a smaller appetite who is losing a little weight, once the GP knows about it.
A prescribed nutrition drink
Called oral nutritional supplements, or ONS
- What it is
- A drink, or sometimes a pudding or powder, prescribed by the GP or a dietitian after a malnutrition screen.
- What it adds
- Energy, protein, vitamins and minerals in a measured amount. A standard bottle gives about 300 calories and 12g of protein; high protein versions give more.
- Who decides
- The GP or dietitian, usually for people at high risk on the MUST screen.
- Who checks it is working
- At least monthly, and stopped once your parent is eating normally again.
- When it fits
- Someone who has lost a lot of weight, is very thin, or is unwell and cannot eat enough food.
The UK guidance for GPs, Managing Adult Malnutrition in the Community, sets out who gets what. At low risk on MUST, the advice is about eating well. At medium risk, it is advice to get more from food and drink, home-made nourishing drinks, or shop nutrition drinks and powders, with a recheck after one to three months. At high risk, the GP considers prescribing nutrition drinks, usually one to three a day between meals, and reviews them at least monthly. They are meant to add to food, never replace it, and they stop once the person is eating normally and is no longer at risk.
If your parent is offered a prescription, the guidance suggests starting with a pack of different flavours to find ones they will drink. It is worth saying at the appointment if they dislike milky drinks, because juice style, yoghurt style and savoury versions exist.
Who should ask first
Kidney disease, diabetes, lactose and swallowing: ask before adding any powder
For some older people extra protein, or the sugar and milk that come with it, needs a professional's say first. These are the situations UK guidance singles out.
Kidney diseaseSection titled Kidney%20disease
A Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust leaflet for people with kidney disease who are not on dialysis says that supplements like protein powders are often not needed and may even be harmful, because too much protein can strain kidneys that are not working well. People on dialysis are the opposite case: they are usually advised to eat more protein, because some is lost during treatment. Either way, the kidney team or a kidney dietitian should decide, and Kidney Care UK has information for patients and families.
DiabetesSection titled Diabetes
Shop protein shakes can contain added sugar, and nutrition drinks are high in energy. The Malnutrition Pathway guidance says diabetes is a reason to take care over which drink is chosen, to spread it through the day, and that diabetes medicines may need adjusting. It also says that diet restrictions given years ago may need relaxing when someone is losing weight. That is a decision for the GP, diabetes nurse or dietitian, not something to change at home.
LactoseSection titled Lactose
Whey, milk powder and many nutrition drinks come from milk. If milk upsets your parent's stomach, read the label or ask the pharmacist. The same guidance lists lactose intolerance among the reasons someone may need a dietitian to choose their supplement.
SwallowingSection titled Swallowing
If your parent coughs at meals, or has been told to have thickened drinks, anything stirred into a drink can change how thick it is. Ask the speech and language therapist or GP before adding anything to their drinks.
Using the muscle
Protein builds muscle only when the muscle is used
Eating more protein without using the muscles does little to make someone stronger. The Malnutrition Pathway guidance pairs protein-rich food with resistance exercise for anyone losing muscle.
The NHS advises adults over 65 to do activities that improve strength, balance and flexibility on at least 2 days a week. Its examples include carrying heavy shopping bags, tai chi, yoga, working with resistance bands and heavy gardening such as digging. A Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS leaflet on protein and exercise says the best results come from a balance of protein in the diet and a mix of exercise that includes strength training, rather than from eating a lot of protein.
If your parent has been unwell or has had a fall, a GP or physiotherapist can say what is safe to start with. Our guide to exercise for older people has more on the kinds of activity that suit later life.
Help at mealtimes
When the problem is getting the meals made and eaten
Shopping, cooking and sitting down to eat can each become hard in later life, even when everyone knows which foods would help.
If that is where things are slipping, talk to the GP about the weight loss first, then build protein into the meals they eat. A carer can do the practical part: shop for the eggs, cheese and yoghurt, make up fortified milk, cook a small meal at lunchtime, offer a milky pudding later, and sit with your parent while they eat, because company at the table can help a small appetite. They can keep a note of what was eaten for the GP review, and offer any prescribed nutrition drinks in the way the GP or dietitian set out. A carer does not give dietary advice or decide on supplements; that stays with the GP and dietitian.
Carers on PrimeCarers are self-employed. You choose the person, meet them first, and agree the visits and the routine with them directly, so a lunchtime visit can be built around the meal plan you already have. You can search for carers near your parent and read their profiles before you get in touch.
Questions
Questions families ask about protein powder
Whey is a protein from milk. For an older person who is eating enough, has healthy kidneys and is fine with milk, a scoop stirred into porridge or a milky drink is a way to add protein. Ask the GP or kidney team first if they have kidney disease, take diabetes medicines, have lost weight without trying or have trouble swallowing. Skimmed milk powder whisked into milk does a similar job with ordinary food.
On its own, probably not much. Putting weight back on needs energy as well as protein, and a sports protein powder is made to add protein, not calories. Nutrition drinks, from the shop or on prescription, give both, with vitamins and minerals. If she has lost weight without trying, start with the GP, who can screen her and prescribe a drink if she is at high risk.
The GP can prescribe nutrition drinks, called oral nutritional supplements, including high protein versions. UK guidance suggests them for people at high risk on the MUST malnutrition screen, usually one to three a day between meals, reviewed at least monthly and stopped once the person is eating normally again.
Food first is the NHS and NICE approach, because food brings energy, vitamins and fibre along with the protein. A powder can fill a gap when appetite is small, as long as the GP knows about any weight loss and there is no kidney disease.
