Today
Make your parent safe, then tell the council's safeguarding team
Whatever you decide about a claim later, the first jobs are the same: your parent's safety, medical care for the harm, and a report to the people whose duty it is to look into it.
If your parent is in danger now, or has an injury that needs treatment, ring 999 or get them to hospital or the GP first. Ask the doctors to record what they find, including the grade of any pressure sore, signs of dehydration and any bruising or fracture. Those notes are written by someone independent of the home, at the time, and they matter later.
Then report it to the adult social care safeguarding team at the council for the area where the care home is. Under section 42 of the Care Act 2014, if the council has reasonable cause to suspect that an adult with care and support needs is experiencing or at risk of abuse or neglect, and cannot protect themselves because of those needs, it must make whatever enquiries it thinks necessary and decide what action should follow and who should take it. You do not need proof to report, and you can report while your parent is still living in the home. Our guide to safeguarding adults and how to report a concern covers the signs, how to make the call and what the enquiry involves.
If your parent is still in the home and you do not feel they are safe there tonight, say so to the safeguarding team and ask what can be put in place straight away. Moving them is your parent's decision if they can make it, and it does not stop any report or claim.
Who can do what
What each organisation can do, matched to what you want
You may want several things at once: your parent safe, someone held to account, the home made to change, and sometimes money for the harm. No single body does all of that. Start from what you want and you can see where to go.
- 1
Your parent kept safe now
Council safeguarding teamits job
Must make whatever enquiries it thinks necessary under section 42 of the Care Act 2014 and decide what action is needed, and by whom.
Policeits job
Ring 999 if someone is in danger now. Officers can attend straight away.
Care Quality Commissioncan play a part
Uses what you tell it to decide whether to inspect or act against the home. It does not resolve one person’s case.
Cannot deliver this: Ombudsman, A claim, Coroner
- 2
Someone to answer for a crime
Policeits job
Investigate ill-treatment or wilful neglect by a care worker, or by the provider that employs them.
Care Quality Commissionits job
Can prosecute the provider when unsafe care or a failure to protect residents causes avoidable harm, or a significant risk of it.
Cannot deliver this: Council, Ombudsman, A claim, Coroner
- 3
The home made to put things right
Care Quality Commissionits job
Inspects, and can take enforcement action against the provider, up to cancelling its registration.
Council safeguarding teamcan play a part
A protection plan can set out what has to change to keep your parent safe.
Social Care Ombudsmancan play a part
Can recommend a change in how the home does things.
Coroner, if your parent diedcan play a part
Must report to whoever can act if an inquest shows a risk of the same thing happening again.
Cannot deliver this: Police, A claim
- 4
Money for the harm done
A claim through a solicitorits job
A negligence claim for compensation, brought by your parent, or by their estate and family if they have died.
Social Care Ombudsmancan play a part
Can recommend a payment as part of putting a complaint right.
Cannot deliver this: Council, Police, CQC, Coroner
- 5
Answers about what happened
Social Care Ombudsmanits job
Investigates your complaint once the home has had its chance to answer.
Coroner, if your parent diedits job
An investigation establishes who the person was, and how, when and where they died.
Council safeguarding teamcan play a part
Establishes the facts in its enquiry. How much you are told depends on your parent’s wishes, or their best interests.
A claim through a solicitorcan play a part
A claim brings out the home’s records and the statements of the staff involved.
Cannot deliver this: Police, CQC
A complaint to the home itself sits alongside all of this. It is the step the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman expects you to have taken before it will look at a case, and a written answer from the home is useful evidence in its own right. Our guide on how to complain about a care home covers who to write to and the ombudsman's time limits. If someone is being harmed, report it as safeguarding first and complain afterwards.
When it may be a crime
Wilful neglect is a crime, and the CQC can prosecute providers as well
Poor care is not always a crime, but some of it is, and there are two separate routes to a criminal court.
The first is the police. Under section 20 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, it is an offence for a paid care worker to ill-treat or wilfully neglect the person they are caring for, with a sentence of up to five years in prison. Section 21 makes it an offence for the care provider too, where a worker ill-treats or wilfully neglects someone and the way the provider runs things is a gross breach of its duty of care that made it happen, or more likely. A provider convicted under section 21 faces an unlimited fine, and the court can order it to put things right and to publicise the conviction (section 23). Ring 999 if someone is in danger now, and 101 to report something that has already happened. Tell the safeguarding team that you have gone to the police, and the police that you have told the council.
The second is the Care Quality Commission. The fundamental standards include safe care and treatment (regulation 12) and protecting residents from abuse and improper treatment, which includes neglect (regulation 13). Regulation 22 makes a breach of either a criminal offence when it causes a resident avoidable harm or puts them at significant risk of it, unless the provider shows it took all reasonable steps to prevent it. Our page on the rules care homes follow sets out each standard. The CQC does not investigate individual complaints, but it wants to hear from you, and you can report a concern to the CQC without giving your name. These four cases reached court.
Manor House Residential Home, Morden
February 2017 · prosecuted by the CQC
Read the CQC news releaseWhat happened
A 79-year-old resident, known to be at high risk of falling, fell against an uncovered radiator and was seriously burned.
The offence
Failing to provide safe care and treatment, resulting in avoidable harm.
How it ended
The owners pleaded guilty and were ordered to pay £24,600 in fines and costs.
A nursing home in Birstall, West Yorkshire
June 2016 · prosecuted by the CQC
Read the CQC news releaseWhat happened
A resident broke his neck in a fall from a shower chair while loosely strapped in, and died. The risk from belts that were not used or adjusted properly was well known.
The offence
Failing to provide safe care and treatment, resulting in avoidable harm.
How it ended
The provider pleaded guilty and was fined £190,000 at Bradford Magistrates’ Court.
Mossley Manor Care Home, Liverpool
March 2017 · prosecuted by the CQC
Read the CQC news releaseWhat happened
Inspectors found no proper system for assessing risks to residents. The home had also not told the CQC when ten residents died, or about three serious incidents.
The offence
Fourteen offences, including exposing residents to a significant risk of avoidable harm.
How it ended
The owners pleaded guilty and were ordered to pay £82,429.72. The CQC had already cancelled the registration and closed the home.
Ash Court Care Centre, Camden
April 2012 · a police investigation
Read the CQC news releaseWhat happened
The family of an 80-year-old resident with dementia secretly filmed a care worker abusing her, and the council’s safeguarding team, the police and the CQC were alerted. The council and the police visited the home the same day.
The offence
Abuse of a resident by an individual care worker.
How it ended
The care worker was sentenced to 18 months, half in custody and half on licence.
Suing for negligence
What a negligence claim against a care home has to prove
A claim for compensation is a civil case, separate from anything the police or the CQC do. It does not need a criminal conviction, and a conviction on its own does not make a claim succeed. It has to prove three things.
A claim needs all three links. If any one of them cannot be shown, the claim fails, however badly the care went.
- 1
A duty of care
The home owed your parent reasonable care.
A care home that takes someone in to look after them owes them a duty to take reasonable care. What it agreed to do is written down before your parent arrived.
Records that show it
- The contract with the home
- The care plan and the home’s assessment before admission
- The council’s needs assessment, if it arranged the place
- 2
A breach of that duty
The care fell below what a reasonably competent home would have given.
This is measured against what a reasonably competent home would have done, and the home’s own daily records are where a gap shows: a turning chart with hours missing, a fluid chart left blank, a falls risk that was assessed and then not acted on.
Records that show it
- Turning (repositioning) charts
- Food and fluid charts
- Falls risk assessments and incident reports
- Medicine records
- The CQC report covering the same months
- 3
Harm caused by the breach
The failure caused harm that would not otherwise have happened.
For a frail older person this is the hardest part to prove, because the home may say the pressure sore, the fall or the decline would have happened anyway. A solicitor asks independent medical experts for their opinion on it.
Records that show it
- Hospital notes from the admission, including any pressure ulcer grading
- Your dated photographs
- GP records from before and after
The claim is brought against the company or organisation that runs the home, not against individual carers, and that is the case whether your parent paid for the place, the council paid or the NHS did. If the home's contract promises things it did not deliver, that is part of the duty as well.
If your parent can make their own decisions, the claim is theirs to bring, with your help. If they lack the mental capacity to run a claim, the court rules say a litigation friend must conduct it for them: a deputy appointed by the Court of Protection with that power, or someone else who can fairly and competently conduct it and has no conflicting interest (Civil Procedure Rules, part 21).
The time limit
Three years, and when the three years start
A claim for an injury has to be started at court within three years. Which date the three years run from depends on your parent's situation, so find the lane that fits.
AYour parent can make their own decisions
Year 1Year 2Year 3From the date of the harm, or the date your parent knew about it, if later.
BYour parent lacked capacity to run a claim when it happened
Paused while they lack capacityYear 1Year 2Year 3Three years from when they regain capacity, or from the date they died.
CYour parent died within the three years
They diedYear 1Year 2Year 3A fresh three years from the date they died, or from when the family or estate knew, if later.
Whether your parent lacked capacity is a question about one decision at one time, and it is assessed rather than assumed from a diagnosis. Our page on mental capacity and how it is assessed explains how. A solicitor will work out the dates for your parent's case at the first conversation, which is one reason not to leave that conversation until the third year.
If your parent died
If your parent died in the home: the coroner and a claim by the family
When someone dies after care that worries the family, two things can follow: a coroner's investigation, which finds out what happened, and a claim, which is about compensation. They run on different rules.
A coroner must investigate if the cause is unknown, or if there is reason to think the person may have died violently or unnaturally, and an investigation that does not end at the post-mortem leads to an inquest. If you think neglect played a part, tell the coroner's office what you know and ask for it to be considered; close family can take part in an inquest and ask witnesses questions. The Ministry of Justice guide to coroner services explains each step, and the Coroners' Courts Support Service gives free support on 0300 111 2141. GOV.UK lists advice when a family member's inquest is coming up among the things legal aid can help with, so ask a solicitor whether it applies before the hearing.
A claim after someone dies has two parts. Their own claim for what they went through carries on for their estate, brought by the executor or administrator. Separately, the Fatal Accidents Act 1976 lets dependants claim for what they have lost, and funeral expenses can be claimed under it too. The fixed bereavement award, £15,120 under section 1A, can only go to a husband, wife or civil partner, or to a partner who lived with them for at least two years. It does not go to adult children, which is a hard thing to learn when it is a widowed parent who has died. The time limit for both parts is in lane C above.
Getting the records
Asking for the care home's records, and your parent's hospital notes
The records listed under each link of the chain above are the evidence. Some you keep yourself, and the rest you have to ask for, and the sooner you ask, the less chance there is of gaps.
Start your own record today. Take dated photographs of any injury, with the hospital's permission if your parent is on a ward. Write down what you saw on each visit, what staff told you and their names, and keep every letter, email and bill from the home. Write it as it happened, without guessing at reasons; a plain, dated account is worth more than an angry one.
For the home's own records, make a subject access request under UK data protection law. The ICO's guide to subject access requests explains how. Organisations usually have one month to respond. You can make the request for your parent if you have their permission, or if you hold a lasting power of attorney for them. Name what you want: the care plan and assessments, daily notes, turning charts, food and fluid charts, falls and incident reports, and medicine records, for the dates that matter. Ask the hospital and the GP for their records in the same way.
Data protection law covers living people only. After someone has died, their health records can be asked for under the Access to Health Records Act 1990 by their personal representative, or by anyone who may have a claim arising from their passing. A solicitor will also ask the home to keep everything once a claim is in view.
A solicitor
Finding a solicitor, and how a claim is paid for
Whether your parent's case is strong is a solicitor's judgement, made on the records and on independent medical evidence. The council, the police and the CQC cannot tell you.
Look for a solicitor who handles personal injury or clinical negligence claims, with experience of care home cases. The Law Society's Find a Solicitor search lists firms by area of law and location, and the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers has a search for accredited injury lawyers, with clinical negligence and abuse among the categories. The first conversation is where you ask whether they think there is a case, how they would fund it, and which of the time limits applies.
Injury claims can be run on a conditional fee agreement, the arrangement known as no win, no fee. If the claim fails you do not pay the solicitor's fee. If it succeeds, the solicitor can take a success fee from the compensation, and in a personal injury claim that fee is capped at 25% of the damages for pain, suffering and past financial losses (Conditional Fee Agreements Order 2013, article 5). Ask for the percentage in writing, and ask about any insurance they recommend and who pays for it. Check household insurance policies as well, because some include legal expenses cover; Citizens Advice lists this among the ways of finding affordable legal help.
Where they live now
Deciding where your parent lives now
A report and a claim deal with what went wrong. Your parent still needs somewhere they are well looked after next week, and that decision cannot wait for either of them.
If the council arranged and pays for the place, talk to the council before you move your parent, because it will need to arrange the new placement or agree a different plan. If your parent pays for themselves, read the contract for the notice period before you give notice. Another care home is one answer, and on the second search it is worth reading the CQC report closely and asking the manager about staffing.
Coming home with care is the other. A live-in carer or regular visits can let your parent leave the home and still have someone with them, and the family can see the care from day to day. If that is the direction you are looking in, you can look at self-employed carers near your parent on PrimeCarers, read their profiles and rates, and meet the ones you like before you agree anything. Every carer has had their identity and right to work checked, an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and an online interview. Carers are insured while they work.
Questions
Questions families ask about care home neglect
Yes. A care home owes its residents a duty of reasonable care. If the care fell below a reasonable standard and that caused harm, the resident, or their estate and family if they have died, can claim compensation. This page covers England; the courts and time limits in Scotland and Northern Ireland are different, so ask a solicitor there.
There is no set figure. Compensation depends on the injury, how long it lasted, what it changed and any financial losses, and a solicitor values it with medical evidence. The only fixed sum in law is the bereavement award under the Fatal Accidents Act 1976, which is for a spouse, civil partner or long-term partner, not for adult children.
Yes. The claim is against the organisation that runs the home, whoever pays for the place. Tell the council about any concern as well, because it arranged the placement and has a duty to make safeguarding enquiries.
You can raise a concern with the CQC without giving your name. A safeguarding report to the council or a police report works better with your details, because they will want to ask you questions, but you can ask the council how they handle your name before you give it.
Yes, if she wants to and her needs can be met elsewhere. Moving her does not stop a safeguarding enquiry, a police investigation or a claim. Our guide to moving from a care home to live-in care covers notice, the council and getting the house ready.
No. A prosecution ends in a fine or a sentence, and a fine goes to the state. Compensation for your parent comes only from a civil claim, which you bring separately. A conviction can still help a claim, because it shows the facts a court has already accepted.
