Valid reasons
The reasons a home can give, and what should come before them
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published advice to UK care homes on consumer law. It says a home can only end a resident's place for a limited set of reasons, and only after trying to put the problem right.
A care home resident is usually a licensee, not a tenant: Age UK lists a care home among the places where you are likely to be a licensee, which means permission to live there without the rights a tenancy gives. That does not leave your relative unprotected. The contract has to say when the home can end the place, the reasons have to be valid, and a term that lets the home end it for any reason, or a vague one, is likely to be unfair and so cannot be enforced. If you have the contract to hand, care home contracts: the clauses to check goes through the rest of it.
Find the reason on the notice letter in the left-hand column below. The right-hand column is what the CMA says should already have happened.
The reason the home gives
What should already have happened
The home can no longer meet her care needs
What should already have happened
The home has made reasonable adjustments to try to meet them, can show the evidence (the CMA mentions recognised dependency tools), and has consulted her, the family and independent professionals such as her GP at an early stage.
CMA advice, paras 4.95(b), 4.103(e)
Fees have repeatedly gone unpaid
What should already have happened
The home told you promptly about the missed payment, looked into why, and gave a fair chance to clear it, for example with a repayment plan. The CMA says a home should not end the contract unless the arrears are significant.
CMA advice, paras 4.95(f), 4.103(h)
The home, or part of it, is closing
What should already have happened
Residents and families should be consulted and told well in advance of a planned closure. If a home closes suddenly, the council has a temporary duty to meet residents’ needs.
CMA advice, para 4.95(d) and footnote 118
She is in hospital and cannot come back
What should already have happened
Only where she is unable to return in the foreseeable future and the absence is not temporary, and only after the home has consulted her and the family.
CMA advice, para 4.95(e)
Violence with a significant risk of serious harm
What should already have happened
The home has tried to understand and manage the behaviour first and consulted the family and professionals. The CMA says this matters especially for people living with dementia, who may not be in full control of their actions.
CMA advice, paras 4.95(g), 4.103(d)
She needs extra care or supported housing the home does not offer
What should already have happened
The same consultation as for a change in needs, with the decision explained and the evidence shared with you.
CMA advice, paras 4.95(c), 4.100, 4.103(g)
What the CMA says is likely to be unfair
- Asking a resident to leave because she or her family made a complaint, including by claiming the home cannot meet her needs when the cause is the complaintpara 4.102(a)
- A contract term letting the home end the place for any reason, or for vague reasons such as the manager feeling she would be better suited elsewhere, or “acrimonious disputes”para 4.93
- Ending the place for breaking any term of the contract, however smallpara 4.93
- Short notice or no notice, or less than 28 days in writingparas 4.96, 4.102(d)
- Saying she agreed to leave in conversation, or putting emotional pressure on her to agreepara 4.102(b), (c)
- Back-dating the notice so the 28 days are shorterpara 4.102(e)
"We can no longer meet her needs" rests on evidence, so it is the reason to look at most closely. Ask what has changed, which assessment shows it, and what the home tried first. If her needs have changed, the right answer may be a different room, more staff time, or a review by her GP or the council's team, rather than a move.
Notice and the court
At least 28 days in writing, and no lock-outs
Whatever the reason, the notice has to be in writing and give at least 28 days. Your relative cannot be put out of the home when it ends unless she agrees to go or a court orders it.
Talk first
Court order
Before any notice
The home should talk to you first
The CMA says the home should explain the problem, try ways of meeting her needs, and consult her, the family, any advocate and professionals such as her GP. Someone senior should review the manager’s decision, or there should be a way to appeal it.
CMA paras 4.100, 4.103(d), (e), (i)
Day 1 to day 28
At least 28 days, in writing
The notice period is the time to ask for the reasons and evidence in writing, use the home’s appeal, ask the council for a review and, if the move goes ahead, plan where she will go. A trial-period stay can have a shorter notice, which still has to give time to make other arrangements.
CMA paras 1.34, 4.103(c)
When the notice ends
She cannot simply be put out
In England and Wales, if she is unwilling to leave when the notice ends, the CMA says the home must apply to court for an order to evict. Similar rules may apply in Scotland. In an emergency, such as an immediate risk of serious harm, the home should contact the council for help.
CMA paras 4.97 to 4.99
The CMA says most residents in England and Wales are legally entitled to at least 28 days' written notice under the Protection from Eviction Act 1977, or longer if the contract says so, and that applies even after a serious breach of the contract unless the resident, or someone lawfully acting for her, agrees to a shorter period. A notice that arrives without warning, is dated earlier than the day you received it, or gives a week is not one the home should be relying on. Being asked to leave is one part of her rights as a resident; care home residents' rights covers the others, from visiting to complaints.
There is one narrow exception the CMA recognises: where a resident poses an immediate and significant risk of serious harm, or her health falls so quickly that the home cannot keep her safe, the home may need to act at once. Even then, it should contact the council for help in finding somewhere suitable, and the CMA notes that the home's responsibility for her can continue until someone else takes over her care.
Notice after a complaint
A complaint is never a reason to end a place
The CMA's guide for residents says a home must not threaten to restrict visitors or ask a resident to leave because a complaint was made. Its advice to homes gives, as an example of an unfair practice, claiming it cannot meet someone's needs when the notice is a reprisal for a complaint.
If the notice came soon after you raised concerns, write down the dates: when you complained, what you complained about, any reply, and when the notice arrived. The timing on its own does not prove why the notice was given, but it belongs in front of anyone who reviews the decision.
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has looked at a case close to this one. A home ended a resident's place after its relationship with her daughter broke down, although it could still meet her needs.
Ombudsman decision 21 015 847
Read the decisionWhat happened
A self-funding resident living with dementia could still have her needs met in the home. After a breakdown in the relationship between her daughter and the home, including two recorded incidents and a heated phone call, the home gave 28 days’ notice. She moved to another home.
What the Ombudsman found
- The home had no basis in its own terms or in the CMA advice for ending the place.
- There were less disruptive ways of dealing with the situation before ending the placement.
- The resident herself was not asked about it until after the decision was made.
- A regional manager involved in the decision also answered the complaint, so nobody independent looked at it.
The decision shows what an independent reviewer expects to see: a reason the contract allows, the resident's own wishes considered, other ways of handling a disagreement tried first, and an appeal heard by someone who was not involved. If the home is unhappy with how a family member behaves, the CMA's advice points to dealing with that behaviour, not to removing the resident.
Who pays changes who to ask
If the council or the NHS pays, they need to know today
Who pays for the place decides who holds the contract and who must look again at her care. Find your relative's row and start there.
She pays for herself
- Who the contract is with
- Between her (or her attorney) and the home. The CMA advice on consumer law applies to its terms.
- Who reviews her care
- She can still ask the council for a needs assessment, and the council can help find somewhere suitable if the home cannot meet her needs.
- Who to tell, and where to complain
- The home’s complaints procedure first, then the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, which looks at privately funded care too.
The council pays some or all of it
- Who the contract is with
- Between the council and the home. Any top-up agreement is made with the council, not the home.
- Who reviews her care
- The council must review her care and support plan on a reasonable request, and a family member can ask. Where it is satisfied her circumstances have changed in a way that affects the plan, it must revise it.
- Who to tell, and where to complain
- Tell her social worker about the notice straight away. Complain to the home and the council, then to the Ombudsman.
The NHS pays (Continuing Healthcare)
- Who the contract is with
- The integrated care board (ICB) arranges and pays for her care, and the home must not let any agreement with her conflict with its contract with the NHS.
- Who reviews her care
- The NHS says a Continuing Healthcare package is normally reviewed within 3 months and then at least once a year. Ask the ICB’s Continuing Healthcare team to review it now.
- Who to tell, and where to complain
- Tell the ICB’s Continuing Healthcare team about the notice. The NHS names Beacon for free independent advice on Continuing Healthcare.
For a council-funded resident, the Care Act 2014 gives you something firm to ask for. Section 27 says the council must review her care and support plan on a reasonable request made on her behalf, and where it is satisfied her circumstances have changed in a way that affects the plan, it must revise the plan, reassessing her as far as it thinks appropriate. Ask for the review in writing, say that the home has given notice, and ask the social worker to speak to the home before the notice runs out. How council-funded care home places work explains the contract between the council and the home in more detail.
If she would struggle to understand or take part in the review, and there is nobody suitable to support her (a family member counts, unless they are paid to care for her), section 67 of the Care Act says the council must arrange an independent advocate.
Challenging the notice
What to write to the home, and who else to involve
The notice period is short, so start several things in the first few days rather than one after another. The first is a letter to the home.
To the home manager, copied to the provider’s senior manager or head office
The notice you gave my mother on [date]
My mother does not agree to leave and has not agreed to leave in any conversation.
A home cannot rely on an oral “agreement” (CMA para 4.102(c)).
Please tell us which term of the contract you are relying on, and the reason in full.
Reasons must be valid and set out in the contract (paras 1.32, 4.103(a), (b)).
Please send the assessments, incident reports and care records the decision is based on, and tell us what adjustments were tried.
The home should disclose the reasons as far as it can and show its evidence (paras 4.103(g), 4.95 footnote 117).
Please tell us who reviewed the decision at a senior level, and how we appeal it.
The manager should not have the only say (para 4.103(i)).
Please confirm the date this notice was served.
Notice must be at least 28 days and not back-dated (para 4.102(d), (e)).
We have asked the council (or the NHS) to review her care, and we would like you to take part.
The placing authority should be involved before a final decision (para 4.103(e)).
Keep a copy, send it by email and by post, and write down the date it went. If you hold a lasting power of attorney for her, say so in the letter.
Alongside the letter, three other routes can run at the same time.
The home's own appeal. The CMA says the home should have someone senior review a manager's decision, or a quick way to appeal it, and should consider mediation where the family disagrees. Ask for both in writing.
A formal complaint, then the Ombudsman. Make a complaint through the home's procedure and, if the council or NHS pays, to them as well. The guide to complaining about a care home sets out how. In England, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman is free and looks at privately funded care as well as council-funded care, but it will only look at a complaint once the home has had the chance to answer it, and it says that should usually take up to 16 weeks. That is longer than the notice, so treat the complaint as a record and a route to a remedy, and keep the other routes going.
Consumer advice. For a self-funding resident, the CMA's residents' guide points to the Citizens Advice consumer helpline, now on 0808 223 1133 (Consumerline on 0300 123 6262 in Northern Ireland), which can pass a complaint to Trading Standards.
If the notice is close to running out and you still disagree with it, speak to a solicitor who works on community care or housing law. This guide sets out what the published guidance says; it cannot tell you how a court would view your relative's case.
If she has to move
If she does have to leave: another home, or home with a carer
Sometimes the reason holds up, or the place has stopped being right for her. The CMA says the home should help her find suitable accommodation, and where the council or NHS pays, they should be part of the plan.
If her needs have grown beyond what a residential home can manage, the next place may be a home with nursing, where a registered nurse is on duty. If she would rather be in her own home, live-in care is the other option to weigh before the notice ends. A self-employed live-in carer lives in her house and helps her get up, wash, dress and use the toilet, cooks, does light housework, prompts the medicines she has been prescribed and notes what was taken, and sleeps in the house at night. A live-in carer is not a nurse, so if she needs nursing on hand at all hours, a home with nursing may still be the right place.
On PrimeCarers, live-in care is typically £1,120 a week with our fee included. You choose the carer from their profile, talk to them, and agree the hours and the routine with them directly. Every carer has had their identity and right to work checked, an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and an online interview. Carers are insured while they work. How soon someone can start depends on who is free near her, so it is worth talking to carers while you are still challenging the notice. Moving from a care home to live-in care covers the council review, the house and the first fortnight at home.
Questions
Questions about being asked to leave a care home
Not in the ordinary way. The CMA says a resident should get at least 28 days' written notice, and in England and Wales a home needs a court order if she has not agreed to leave when the notice ends. The only exception it describes is an emergency, such as an immediate risk of serious harm, and then the home should contact the council for help in finding somewhere safe.
Only where fees have repeatedly gone unpaid and significant arrears remain. Before that, the CMA says the home should tell you promptly, look into why a payment was missed and give a fair chance to catch up, for example through a repayment plan. If the council pays part of the fee and a top-up has stopped, talk to the council: the top-up agreement is with them.
Only where there is a significant risk of serious harm and the home has tried to understand and manage the behaviour first, with the family and professionals involved. The CMA says this matters especially for people living with dementia, who may not be in full control of their actions. Ask what the home has tried, and whether her GP or the community mental health team have been involved.
Only if she cannot return in the foreseeable future, the absence is not temporary, and the home has consulted her and the family first. The CMA suggests a review after a set period, for example 6 to 8 weeks, to agree what happens to her room. Trial stays and coming home again covers the options if she may not go back.
Less than 28 days, but still enough to make other arrangements. The CMA gives seven days as an example of adequate notice during a trial, and says a home ending a trial early should refund fees paid for any time beyond the notice period.
The CMA advice covers care homes for older people across the UK. The rule about a court order applies in England and Wales, and the CMA says similar provisions may apply in Scotland. The CMA's residents' guide names the Care Inspectorate as a place to take complaints in Scotland. In Northern Ireland the consumer helpline is Consumerline.
