Why arguing fails
Why the facts do not change their mind
If you have explained, shown the bank statement, and explained again, and your mother still says the money has been taken, you have not done it badly. The tools that let a person accept a correction are the ones dementia damages.
The NHS lists memory, understanding and judgement among the brain functions dementia affects. Reasoning with somebody asks for all three at once: they have to hold what you said, follow why it is so, and weigh it against what they believe. When the first link goes, the rest goes with it, and the conversation starts again from the beginning a few minutes later. It gets harder as the condition moves on, and the dementia care guide covers how the stages change day-to-day life.
What an argument needs, and dementia wears away
Holding on to what they have just been told
Your explanation can be gone by the time you have finished it, so the same question comes back.
Following a chain of reasons
Understanding and judgement are among the functions the NHS lists as affected, and an argument needs both.
Long sentences and open questions
Each extra idea is another thing to hold while working out the answer.
What tends to stay
How a conversation felt
The Mental Health Foundation inquiry notes that emotional memory can remain even when short-term factual memory no longer works properly.
Older memories
Long-term memories tend to dominate as short-term memory fails, which is why they may be living in an earlier year.
Tone, faces and gestures
In the later stage, the Alzheimer's Society says people may still understand gestures, facial expressions and body language.
What stays is the important half. The Mental Health Foundation's inquiry into truth in dementia care found that a person can keep their emotional memory, the ability to have feelings, even when their short-term memory for facts no longer works properly. So an argument they lose leaves them with the feeling of being told they are wrong, or that something frightening is true, long after the details have gone. Winning the point does not stop the belief coming back, and the bad feeling can build up over a day of arguments.
Five ways to answer
Five ways to answer a belief you know is wrong
In 2016 the Mental Health Foundation published What is Truth?, an inquiry funded by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation into how carers answer people with dementia whose reality differs from their own. Its panel set out five responses on a line from the whole truth to a lie, and agreed that you start as close to the truth as you can.
- 1The truthTelling the whole truth
- 2Its meaningLooking for what they mean
- 3DistractDistracting
- 4Go alongGoing along with it
- 5LieLying
Start here, and move right only if the truth would cause needless distress
Only to prevent harm
More untruth, and more discomfort for whoever says it
“Where is John? He should be home by now.”
Her husband died some years ago. Five ways to answer, adapted from the inquiry's own example.
Telling the whole truth
“I'm so sorry, Mum. Dad died a few years ago.”
Where to start, said gently. Worth trying again another day even if it upset them once, because memory and perception change.
Looking for what they mean
“You're missing him. Tell me about him. How did you two meet?”
Finds out whether it is John she wants, or the company and comfort he stood for, which someone else can give.
Distracting
“I'm not sure, but come and see the tulips with me while the sun is out.”
A temporary measure. Acknowledge the worry first, and choose something they enjoy, or it can make things worse.
Going along with it
“It's only half past two. He always did work hard, your John.”
Stepping into their world without confirming or denying it. Some carers told the inquiry it was their most used and most compassionate response.
Lying
“He rang. He'll be home at six and we'll all have tea.”
Adding false facts of your own. The panel felt this should be kept for extreme moments, to prevent physical or psychological harm.
The middle three are the everyday answers, and the inquiry drew a clear line between them and lying. Going along with your father when he says he has to get to work, asking what the job involves and what he is worried about missing, is meeting him where he is. Telling him the office rang to say he has the day off is building a story of your own, and the panel felt that was unnecessary and, in most cases, morally wrong. Its other principles are practical: avoid fake settings designed to deceive, give the same answer whichever member of the family is asked, and write down what works.
The Mental Health Foundation's report is short and readable, and worth passing to anyone else in the family who is being asked the same questions.
Whether to correct
Deciding whether to correct them
Two questions help you decide: is the belief upsetting them, or putting anyone at risk, and what happened the last time you told them the truth?
The truth has not upset them before
The truth has upset them before
The belief is not upsetting them or anyone else
The truth has not upset them before
You can let it go
The Alzheimer's Society says a mistaken belief that causes no harm or anxiety may not need correcting. If it comes up naturally, a light, kind correction is fine.
The truth has upset them before
Leave it alone
Correcting a contented person has upset them before, so there is nothing to gain. Go along with it and enjoy the conversation.
The belief is upsetting them, or putting someone at risk
The truth has not upset them before
Tell them, kindly
If the truth settled them last time, it may help again. Say it once, simply, and stay with them while they take it in.
The truth has upset them before
Answer the feeling first
Look for what they need, then move on to something they enjoy. Keep any untruth for a moment when someone could be hurt.
The inquiry is clear that the truth is not something to give up on for good. A person's memory and perception change, so a truth that caused tears in the spring may be taken calmly in the autumn, and it is reasonable to try again. It also points out that a good life with dementia includes some sadness and disagreement, so a moment of upset is not by itself a reason to avoid the truth. What you are trying to avoid is the same distress, again and again, for no gain.
One kind of belief needs checking before you answer it. When someone with dementia says money has gone, or that a person has been unkind to them, the Alzheimer's Society advises not assuming automatically that it is untrue, and looking into whether it is. Look at bank statements, notice who has been visiting, and listen to the detail. If it turns out to be a mislaid purse, you have lost nothing by taking it seriously.
When they are angry
When they are angry with you
An accusation from a parent or partner is hard to hear without defending yourself. Defending yourself is the argument, though, and it can make the anger last longer.
The Alzheimer's Society's advice on delusions is not to try to argue with or correct the person, but to acknowledge their feelings, reassure them that their concerns are being taken seriously, and let them talk, because what they say may show what is behind the belief. Its communication advice says that if someone is upset, let them express their feelings.
The Mental Health Foundation inquiry gives an example that may sound familiar. A mother accuses her daughter of taking her shoes, which have only been mislaid. If the daughter defends herself, there is an argument. If she finds the shoes and hands them back with an apology, her mother forgives her and relaxes. The daughter has not admitted to anything that matters; she has chosen the relationship in that moment over being right.
You do not have to stay in the room while someone shouts at you. Saying you will make a cup of tea and coming back in ten minutes gives you both time. If anger is turning into pushing or hitting, or happens at the same time each day, what triggers aggression and agitation in dementia covers the physical causes to rule out and how to keep yourself safe.
When to ring the GP
Delusions, hallucinations, and when to ring the GP
A false belief and something seen that is not there are different things, and both can have a medical cause. The difference matters to the doctor, so it helps to describe which you are seeing.
A delusion is a strongly held false belief, such as being certain that a purse has been stolen or that a partner is being unfaithful. A hallucination, in the Alzheimer's Society's words, is an experience of something that is not there: seeing people or animals in the room, or hearing voices. The Alzheimer's Society says both are more common in dementia with Lewy bodies, and the NHS lists hallucinations among its symptoms, with confusion and sleepiness that can change over minutes or hours.
Reasoning helps least with hallucinations, because to the person the thing is there. The Alzheimer's Society advises staying with them, explaining calmly what is happening, and not arguing, because trying to convince someone they are mistaken can lead to more distress. If the diagnosis is Lewy body dementia, read the warning about medicines in Lewy body dementia before anyone suggests a prescription for hallucinations.
How to say it
Saying it in short sentences, one idea at a time
Whichever answer you choose, how you say it decides a lot. The Alzheimer's Society's tips come down to fewer words, more time, and talking about what they can still reach.
“Do you remember when we went to Whitby? You must remember, you bought that hat.”
“I was thinking about Whitby today. You bought a hat with a blue ribbon.”
Talk about the memory yourself, so they can join in with whatever they recall, rather than testing them.
“What would you like for lunch?”
“Soup or a sandwich?”
Open questions are hard. Two choices keep the decision theirs without too many options.
“Get your coat, we need to leave by ten because the appointment is at half past and parking is awful.”
“Here's your coat.” Then, once it is on: “We're going to see the doctor.”
One idea at a time, with a pause for each to land.
“Nobody has taken your purse, Mum. You've put it somewhere again.”
“That's horrible, thinking your purse has gone. Let's look for it together.”
The worry is acknowledged and the search is shared, with nothing to argue about.
Its advice is to use short, simple sentences, stick to one idea at a time, avoid too many open questions, and leave time between sentences for an answer. Speak clearly and calmly, and do not slip into a high-pitched voice or talk down to them. Do not try to jog their memory with "do you remember"; talk about what you remember, so they can join in with what they can recall without being tested.
That last point answers the question of what to talk about. The past, told by you, is good ground, because the Mental Health Foundation inquiry notes that older memories tend to last longer than recent ones: their first job, the street they grew up on, the dog they had, the songs from their twenties. Things in front of you work too, such as the birds on the feeder, the photograph on the shelf, or what is cooking. In the later stage, words matter less. The Alzheimer's Society says people may still understand gestures, facial expressions and body language, and often respond more to the senses than to words. A hand held, a familiar song or a favourite smell can say what a sentence no longer does. How to talk to someone with dementia covers everyday conversation in more depth.
Questions
Questions families ask
Some of it, and less as the condition moves on. The Alzheimer's Society says people in the later stage may understand fewer words but may still understand gestures, facial expressions and body language. Your tone and your face carry a lot of the message, so keep both calm even when the words are not getting through.
Use very few words, get to their eye level, and give them time. Touch, music and familiar smells and textures can reach them when conversation does not. Watch their face and hands for how they are feeling, since they may not be able to tell you.
Answer it as if it is the first time, using the reply your family has agreed, and look for the worry behind it. When someone with dementia keeps asking the same question goes through why it happens and what helps.
The Mental Health Foundation inquiry concluded that blatant lies, where a carer starts a false story of their own, should only be used in extreme circumstances to avoid physical or psychological harm. Going along with what someone already believes, without adding false details, is different, and some carers told the inquiry it was their most compassionate response.
