PrimeCarers

Dementia careDay to day

How to talk to someone with dementia, and what not to say

Talk to the person rather than about them, in short sentences with one idea at a time, and answer the feeling behind what they say instead of correcting the facts. What changes with each stage is how much your words carry: early on, keep them in every conversation; in the middle, offer two choices and stop arguing with beliefs you cannot change; later, your tone, your touch, music and their name do most of the work.

By , founder of PrimeCarers  ·  Updated  ·  14 min read

Part of our guide to dementia care.

What gets through

Why the usual way of talking stops working

If conversations with your mum, dad or partner keep ending in an argument, tears or silence, it does not mean you are doing it badly. The way you have always talked to them relies on things the dementia is taking away.

Ordinary conversation leans on memory and speed. We ask about yesterday, we pack three ideas into a sentence, and we correct each other when a detail is wrong. Dementia makes each of those harder: recent events go first, it takes longer to take in a sentence and find an answer, and a mistake that is pointed out can feel like being caught out rather than helped.

What does not go is the ability to read you. The Alzheimer's Society says that a person with dementia may still understand a lot of what you are saying even when they respond less, and Social Care Wales notes that as dementia progresses, people rely more and more on the other person's non-verbal communication. Your face, your voice and how close you stand are being read the whole time, at every stage. That is why a correct sentence said with a sigh can go worse than a muddled one said warmly.

What gets through to them, as the dementia moves on

Early
Follows most conversation, tires with fast or crowded talk
Middle
Loses the thread of long sentences and of recent events
Later
Few words, or none; responds more to senses than words
  • Long sentences and questions about the past

    These go first, and questions about the past start to feel like tests.

    Early

    Middle

    Later

  • Short sentences, one idea at a time

    Works for a long time, then fewer words get through.

    Early

    Middle

    Later

  • Your tone of voice and your face

    Reaches them at every stage, even when the words do not.

    Early

    Middle

    Later

  • Touch, music and their own name

    These carry more as words carry less.

    Early

    Middle

    Later

Carries most of the meaningCarries some
A sketch drawn from NHS, Alzheimer's Society and Social Care Wales guidance, not a measurement. Every person moves at their own pace, and there can be good and bad days within the same stage.

So it helps to lean on the things that still reach them, and which of those matter most shifts as the dementia moves on.

Stage by stage

How to talk to them at each stage

The advice is broadly the same throughout, but what matters most shifts as the dementia moves on. Find the panel that sounds like your parent or partner on a typical day, and look at the one after it too, because good and bad days can sit a stage apart.

  1. Early stageAt the GP, with Dad beside you

    What has changed

    He follows the conversation but needs a little longer to answer, and notices when people talk over him.

    • Speak to him, not about him, even when it would be quicker to answer for him.
    • Let him speak for himself about his own health, and wait for the answer.
    • Ask before you take over a task, a phone call or a letter.

    Instead of

    “He's been forgetting things for months, haven't you, Dad?”

    Try

    “Dad, do you want to tell the doctor what's been happening, or shall I start and you put me right?”

  2. Middle stageIn the kitchen at lunchtime

    What has changed

    Long sentences and open questions lose her. Recent events and some facts have gone, and she may believe things that are not true.

    • One idea per sentence, and a choice of two rather than an open question.
    • Show as well as say: point, hold things up, do it alongside her.
    • Leave a belief alone if it is doing no harm, and answer the feeling under it.

    Instead of

    “What would you like for lunch? There's soup, or I could do eggs, or we could have the quiche from yesterday.”

    Try

    “Soup or a sandwich?”

    Holding one in each hand.

  3. Later stageBeside his chair, on a quiet afternoon

    What has changed

    He says little or nothing, but still reads your face, your voice and your hands.

    • Start with his name and yours, and keep your voice slow and warm.
    • Touch his hand or arm if he is comfortable with it, and watch his face for the answer.
    • Music, a familiar smell or a soft blanket can reach him when words do not.

    Instead of

    “Do you know who I am? It's me. Come on, say hello.”

    Try

    “Hello Dad, it's Ruth.”

    Sitting at his level, a hand on his arm, his favourite song playing.

Early stage: keep them in the conversationSection titled Early%20stage%3A%20keep%20them%20in%20the%20conversation

In the early stage, being talked over or left out can hurt more than the confusion itself. It is tempting to answer for them at the GP, or to talk to the doctor across them, because it is quicker and you know the history. The NHS advises letting the person speak for themselves about their own health and welfare, and the Alzheimer's Society asks families not to talk as if the person is not there. Give them time to answer, and if you need to add something, ask first.

Middle stage: one idea, two choices, no argumentsSection titled Middle%20stage%3A%20one%20idea%2C%20two%20choices%2C%20no%20arguments

This is the stage where long sentences and open questions start to lose them. Use short sentences with one idea in each, and replace open questions with a choice of two, holding the options up if you can. The NHS advises giving simple choices and avoiding complicated ones, and the Alzheimer's Society suggests not asking too many open questions. If they say something that is not true, the Alzheimer's Society's advice is to think about whether it needs correcting at all: if it is causing no harm or anxiety, you may not need to, and joining them where they are is kinder than proving the facts.

Later stage: tone, touch, music and their nameSection titled Later%20stage%3A%20tone%2C%20touch%2C%20music%20and%20their%20name

Later on, words may shrink to a few or go altogether, but the Alzheimer's Society says people may still be able to understand gestures, facial expressions and body language, and often respond more to senses than words. Sit at their level, say their name first and then yours, and keep your voice slow and warm. Dementia UK suggests touching their arm if they are comfortable with it, and the Alzheimer's Society notes that people in the later stage may like listening to songs. A few minutes of a favourite record and a held hand is a conversation, even if neither of you says much. Making someone with dementia happy has more on building the day around what they still enjoy.

Phrases to swap

Eight things not to say, and what to say instead

These are the phrases that slip out when you are tired, worried or in a hurry, and most of the swaps follow the Alzheimer's Society's guidance on what not to say. Nobody gets them right every time. If one slips out, let it go and try the swap next time.

  1. “Do you remember when we went to Whitby?”

    “I remember when we went to Whitby. You made us eat chips in the rain.”

    Why: A question about the past is a test they can fail, and failing it in front of you is embarrassing. Starting with "I remember" lets them join in without being tested.

  2. “Your mum died years ago. You went to the funeral.”

    “You're thinking about your mum. What was she like?”

    Why: Hearing it again can land as if for the first time, with the grief that goes with it. Asking for a parent can be about wanting comfort or safety, so answer that.

  3. “You already asked me that. Three times.”

    “The hairdresser is on Thursday. I'll take you.”

    The same short answer, in the same calm voice, as if it were the first time.

    Why: They do not remember asking. The question can come from a worry, and pointing out the repeat adds embarrassment to the worry.

  4. “Calm down. There's nothing to get upset about.”

    “I can see this has upset you. I'm here.”

    Then lower your voice, step back and give them room.

    Why: Being told to calm down tells someone their feeling is wrong, which tends to raise it. Naming the feeling and giving space lets it pass.

  5. “No, that's wrong. It was 1962, not 1958.”

    “That was a good year for you two.”

    Why: If a mistaken detail is doing no harm, correcting it wins the point and loses the conversation.

  6. “What did you do this morning?”

    “I've just come from the market. The strawberries are in.”

    Why: A question about recent events can be impossible to answer. Talking about your own day, or what is in front of you, gives them something to respond to.

  7. “Let's get your coat on, then we'll find your bag, and we'll pick up Jean on the way to lunch.”

    “Let's put your coat on.”

    Then the bag. Then the car.

    Why: By the end of a long sentence the start has gone. One step at a time is easier to follow and easier to agree to.

  8. “There we go, love, good girl. Let's have our tea now, shall we?”

    “Margaret, here's your tea.”

    Why: Talking to an adult like a child is noticed, even late on. Use their name and your normal voice.

Repeated questions can wear you down, and there is more to do about them than keeping your patience. When someone with dementia keeps asking the same question covers why it happens and the notes, clocks and routines that cut it down.

Beliefs that are not true

When they believe something that is not true

Your dad says he has to get to work. Your mum is sure someone has taken her purse. Arguing with the belief tends to leave both of you upset without changing it. What to do instead depends on what the belief means to them.

Start with the feeling, not the fact. "I need to get to work" may mean he feels useless and wants something to do; a missing purse may mean she feels unsafe or that things are slipping away from her. Answering that ("You've always worked so hard. Will you help me with this first?", or "Let's look for it together") goes further than proving the facts. Helping to look is better than defending yourself, even when the accusation stings.

Families and professionals disagree about how far to go along with a belief, and it is worth knowing both sides. Some feel that any untruth undermines trust and treats the person as less than an adult. Others feel that repeating painful facts, such as a parent who has died or a home that was sold years ago, is cruel when it changes nothing. The Mental Health Foundation's inquiry into truth and lying in dementia care did not take either extreme. Its principles begin with finding out what a belief means to the person, then start as close to the whole truth as possible, and keep deliberate untruths for extreme circumstances.

Start at the top, and step down only as far as you need to

Closest to the whole truth

  1. Find out what the belief means

    First, whatever you do next

    A belief that is not true can still mean something: wanting to be useful, feeling unsafe, missing someone.

    "You're worried about the children. Tell me about them."

  2. Tell the truth, gently

    Unless it would cause needless distress

    The inquiry says responses should start as close to the whole truth as possible.

    "It's Tuesday, so it's the day the carer comes."

  3. Meet them in their reality

    When the truth would only cause distress

    Going along with what they believe, without adding new untruths of your own.

    "They're lucky to have you looking out for them. Shall we have a cup of tea?"

  4. A deliberate untruth

    Only in extreme circumstances

    The inquiry says a blatant untruth started by a carer may only be used to avoid physical or psychological harm.

    Not a habit, and never to make the day easier for you.

Furthest from it

From the six principles in the Mental Health Foundation's 2016 inquiry, "What is truth?". It also asks families and carers to keep their responses the same, and to write down what does and does not work.

Whatever your family decides, decide it together. The inquiry asks for responses to be kept consistent, because a belief that is gently accepted by one person and flatly contradicted by the next is more confusing than either approach on its own.

Can you reason with someone with dementia? goes further into why logic stops working, and the difference between delusions and hallucinations.

Visiting, and friends

If they will not remember the visit, and what to say to a friend

Some people stop visiting because the person no longer seems to know them, or because the visits feel pointless if they are forgotten by teatime. Others do not know what to say to a friend whose parent has dementia.

A visit that is forgotten afterwards can still be a good hour while it lasts. The Alzheimer's Society says people may still understand a lot of what you say, and in the later stage respond to senses more than words, so your company, your voice and something to hold or listen to still reach them. Choose the time of day when they are usually at their brightest, and keep the visit short enough that neither of you gets tired. Say who you are as you come in, and bring something to look at together, such as photographs, or sit by a window onto the garden. If you find the visits very hard, that is worth saying to someone; it does not mean you should stop.

If it is a friend whose parent or partner has dementia, ask how they are and listen to the answer, without hurrying to reassure them. Practical offers help more than general ones: "Can I sit with your dad on Thursday afternoon so you can get out?" is easier to accept than "Let me know if there's anything I can do." Try not to say that the person "doesn't know what's going on" or "won't remember anyway", because for the family that is the hardest part, not a comfort.

What a carer does

What a carer used to dementia does that you can copy

Good dementia care at home leans on a handful of habits, and none of them needs special technique. Most come down to having time, and to not carrying the history you carry.

They introduce themselves every time, by name, even on the fifth visit of the week. They say what they are about to do before they do it ("I'm going to help with your sleeve now") and do one step at a time. They wait for an answer for longer than feels comfortable. They do not correct a story they have heard before; they ask a question about it. And when something is going badly, they stop, step back and come back to it ten minutes later, without taking it personally. That last part is much easier for someone who is not also grieving the parent they used to have.

Try one or two of the swaps tonight. If you would like someone who has the time to talk with your mum or dad on the days you cannot, you can look at carers near you and read their profiles. If your parent is more at ease in their first language, you can look for a carer who speaks it, such as an Urdu speaking carer or a carer who speaks Gujarati. On PrimeCarers, a carer's dementia experience is their own account on their profile, and PrimeCarers does not check training or qualifications, so ask them at interview how they would answer "Where's my mother?" or "Who are you?". You choose the carer, meet them first and agree the hours directly, and you can keep the same person each visit, which matters with dementia because a familiar face and voice are easier to trust. Every carer has their identity and right to work checked, has an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and is interviewed online. Carers are insured while they work.

Questions

Questions families ask about talking to someone with dementia

Less and less as the dementia moves on, because reasoning relies on memory and on following several steps at once. In the early stage a calm explanation can still work. Later, it is usually better to respond to how they feel than to try to win the point. Can you reason with someone with dementia? explains why.

The phone takes away your face and your hands, which are much of what reaches her, so keep calls short and simple. Say who you are as soon as she answers ("Hi Mum, it's Ruth"), ring from somewhere quiet, and ask one thing at a time. A regular time each day can help her expect the call. If calls often upset her, a short visit or a video call where she can see you may go better.

Do not quiz them about the past, argue with a belief that is doing no harm, talk about them in front of them, rush them for an answer or talk to them like a child. If they become angry or frightened, step back and give them room rather than trying to calm them down with words. Aggression and agitation in dementia covers what to check and what helps in the moment.

Looking for someone with time to talk?

Search carers near you, read what they say about their experience with dementia, and message the ones you like. You choose who to meet, and it is free to search.

Free to searchNo obligationID and DBS checkedYou choose the carer