PrimeCarers

Dementia careDay to day

When someone with dementia keeps asking the same question

Answer the worry behind the question as well as the question itself, use the same short answer each time, and leave that answer somewhere they can see it, on a clock, a whiteboard or a card by the phone. They are not doing it on purpose: dementia stops the answer from being stored, so the worry that prompted the question comes back. If the repeating has come on suddenly, with new confusion, get medical help straight away. And if hearing it fifty times a day is wearing you down, regular breaks are what let you keep going.

By , founder of PrimeCarers  ·  Updated  ·  7 min read · What to say

Part of our guide to dementia care.

Why it happens

Why someone with dementia asks the same question again and again

The question is not a test of your patience, and they are very unlikely to know they have asked it before.

Dementia affects the parts of the brain that make new memories. The Alzheimer's Society explains that recent events are not recorded in the person's memory, so they cannot be recalled later, and a conversation you have just had may be forgotten. When you answer, the answer settles them for a moment. Then it fades, and whatever made them ask in the first place is still there.

That is why a worry can sit behind the question. The NHS says repeating the same question may come from memory loss, and that the person is not being deliberately difficult. The Alzheimer's Society adds that the person very likely does not know they keep asking, and that repeated questions can come from feeling confused or anxious. Our dementia care guide covers how memory and behaviour change across the stages.

Why the same question comes back

  1. A worry comes up

    Am I late for something? Where is my purse? Has anyone told Sarah?

  2. They ask you

    The question is the nearest way to put the worry into words.

  3. You answer, and they settle

    For a moment the worry is gone, and so is the question.

  4. The answer is not kept

    Dementia stops new memories forming, so the answer fades. The feeling that started it does not.

Two places you can loosen the loop

  • At the worry

    Answer the feeling as well as the question

    If the worry is settled, there is less to start the loop again.

  • At the answer

    Leave the answer where they can see it

    A clock, a board or a card answers the next time without anyone being asked.

The Alzheimer’s Society says the person very likely does not know they keep asking, and may need comfort or reassurance more than the answer itself.

What to say

Answer the worry, in the same short words each time

The Alzheimer's Society says the person may need comfort, security or reassurance more than the repeated answer to their question.

Before you answer, think about what might be behind the question. The Alzheimer's Society gives the example of someone asking what day it is: the worry may be that they have forgotten something, and the answer "Monday" does nothing for that. Telling them there is nothing they need to do today does.

  1. They ask: “What day is it?”

    They may be worried they have forgotten something they should be doing.

    You could say: “It’s Tuesday. There’s nothing you need to do today, so we can take it easy.”

  2. They ask: “When are we having lunch?”

    They may be hungry, bored, or worried there is not enough food in the house.

    You could say: “At one o’clock. The fridge is full. Shall we have a cup of tea while we wait?”

  3. They ask: “Where’s my purse?”

    They may feel that things, and money, are slipping out of their control.

    You could say: “It’s in the dish by the front door, where it always lives. Let’s go and look together.”

  4. They ask: “When is Sarah coming?”

    They may be missing her, or feeling on their own.

    You could say: “Saturday. It’s written on the calendar. Tell me about the time she was in the school play.”

  5. They ask: “Have I taken my tablets?”

    They may be worried about getting something wrong.

    You could say: “Yes, with your breakfast. I’ve written it on the board so you can see.”

Use the same words each time. A familiar answer is easier to take in than a new one, and you do not have to think of something fresh on the twentieth asking.

Keep the answer short. The NHS advises speaking clearly and slowly in short sentences, and being patient and calm. The Alzheimer's Society also suggests keeping your tone level and calm, even on the tenth asking.

Avoid "I've already told you" or "You asked me that five minutes ago". They have no memory of asking, so all they hear is that they have done something wrong, and the worry gets bigger. If the same answer stops working, a change of scene can help: the Alzheimer's Society suggests an activity they enjoy to shift their focus. That might be a walk, sorting the washing together or a cup of tea in the garden, whatever they have always liked. Our guide on how to talk to someone with dementia has more on what to say when they believe something that is not true.

Answers in the house

Leave the answer where they can see it

A written answer can be read again and again without anyone being asked. The Alzheimer's Society suggests a calendar or clock where the person can easily see it, and a set place for the things they keep looking for.

Put each answer where the question gets asked

Living roomKitchenHallTVFront door12345
  1. A dementia clock by their chair

    Answers: What day is it? Is it morning or evening?

  2. A calendar on the wall, with each day crossed off and visits written in

    Answers: When is Sarah coming? Is it the weekend?

  3. A whiteboard with today written on it: who is coming, what is for lunch, the time the tablets were taken

    Answers: What are we doing today? Have I had my tablets? When is lunch?

  4. A card by the phone with the times you will ring

    Answers: When will you ring? Has Sarah rung today?

  5. One dish by the door for the purse, keys and glasses

    Answers: Where is my purse? Where are my keys?

Large, plain writing works best. Keep the board to today only, and wipe it each evening so yesterday’s plan is not read as tomorrow’s.

Put each answer where the question tends to come up, and write it the way you would say it: "Sarah is coming on Saturday" rather than "S. Sat". When they ask, point to the board as well as answering, so the written answer and your answer go together. Some people stop asking about one subject once it is written down; others will still ask and need you to read it with them. Both are fine.

A clock that shows the day, the date and whether it is morning or evening answers questions about the day and the time without anyone being asked. Our page on what a dementia clock is explains how they differ from an ordinary clock and where to get one.

Repeated phone calls

When the same question comes by phone

If you do not live with them, the repeating may reach you as call after call. The same ideas apply, with a few changes to how the phones are set up.

Ring at fixed times, and write those times on the card by their phone: "Sarah rings at 10am and 6pm every day." A call they know is coming can settle the worry before it turns into another call. When you do answer an unexpected call, keep to the same short answer you use in person, and finish by saying when you will ring next.

Record your voicemail greeting in your own voice with the same reassurance: "Hello Mum, it's Sarah. Everything is fine. I'll ring you at six." If you cannot pick up, they still hear you. A simpler phone with photo buttons can help too, so they reach you, or the brother or sister sharing the calls, without dialling. Our guide for when an elderly parent keeps calling you goes through the phone settings and the card by the phone in more detail.

If it started suddenly

If the repeating comes on suddenly, get medical help straight away

Repetition that builds slowly is part of dementia. Repetition that appears over hours or a day or two may be something else.

How much they repeat, over time

Over weeks and months

The questions come a little more often as memory changes. This is part of how dementia progresses.

Mention it at the next GP or memory clinic review, along with anything else that has changed.

How much they repeat, over time

Over hours, or a day or two

Much more confused and repetitive than yesterday, perhaps more anxious, distressed or unsure where they are. This can be delirium, and Dementia UK lists infections such as a urine infection among its causes.

Get help straight away. The NHS says to go to A&E or call 999 if someone suddenly becomes confused. Dementia UK says you can also ask the GP for an urgent appointment.

Sources: Dementia UK on delirium, and the NHS page on confusion.

Dementia UK describes delirium as intense confusion that comes on suddenly, over one or two days or even a few hours, and lists infections such as a urine infection, constipation, pain, not eating or drinking enough and some medicines among its causes. The NHS says to go to A&E or call 999 if someone suddenly becomes confused, because many causes of sudden confusion need to be assessed and treated as soon as possible. Dementia UK says that if the person is at home, you can contact their GP and ask for an urgent appointment, and call 999 or go to A&E if they seem seriously or suddenly unwell. Our guide to urine infections and sudden confusion explains what to look for and what to tell the GP.

Your patience

Keeping your patience, and getting regular breaks

You will lose your temper sometimes. That does not make you a bad husband, wife, son or daughter. It means you have been answering the same question all day with no one to take a turn.

When you feel it rising, step away for a few minutes if it is safe to do so. Dementia UK suggests going into another room and taking a breath until you feel calmer. Then come back with the same short answer and start again.

Dementia UK also says it is not possible to care for someone on your own 24 hours a day. A regular break, on the same days each week, gives you something to hold on to on the hard afternoons. It also gives the person a familiar face who is not you, someone who answers the question with fresh patience because they have not heard it all day.

Two afternoons a week that are yours

MonTueWedThuFriSatSun

A carer with them from 1pm to 4pm on Tuesday and Friday: six hours out of the eighty-four between 8am and 8pm.

One afternoon a week (3 hours)
£54 to £75 a week
Two afternoons a week (6 hours)
£108 to £150 a week
Three hours every weekday (15 hours)
£270 to £375 a week
Hourly carers on PrimeCarers charge £18 to £25 an hour, with our fee included.

A carer can sit with them, answer the questions with the same words you use, keep the whiteboard up to date, make lunch, go for a walk with them and help with washing and dressing. Carers on PrimeCarers are self-employed. You choose the carer from their profile, meet them first, and agree the hours and the routine with them directly, so the same person can come each week. Every carer has their identity and right to work checked, an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and an online interview. Carers are insured while they work. Dementia experience is the carer's own account on their profile, so ask about it when you meet.

You may not have to pay for all of it. In England, under the Care Act 2014, the council must carry out a carer's assessment for anyone who appears to need support, whatever their level of need or their finances, and the support it leads to can include breaks from caring. In Scotland the same help comes through an adult carer support plan. The respite care guide explains the kinds of break and how they are paid for.

Book cover for a break

Tell us when you need cover, what kind and where, and we will set your account up as you go.

Questions

Questions about repeated questions

Repetition may be because of memory loss, and the Alzheimer’s Society says some repeated actions, such as zipping and unzipping a cardigan, can seem anxious. If a repeated word is not causing harm or upsetting them, it suggests accepting that it may be comforting and letting it be. If it comes with distress, mention it to the GP. If it started suddenly with new confusion, follow the NHS advice in the section above.

Questions that come a little more often over months are part of how dementia changes, and worth mentioning at the next review. A change over hours or a day or two is different and needs urgent help, as the section above explains. Our guide to signs that dementia is getting worse covers the slower changes.

Contact adult social services at the council for the area where the person you care for lives (in Wales, your own council; in Northern Ireland, the Health and Social Care Trust). Carers UK says anyone over 18 who gives regular unpaid care is entitled to one, whether or not the person they care for has had a needs assessment. Our guide on what a carer’s assessment is explains what happens.

Want someone to take a turn?

Search hourly carers near you, read their profiles and rates, and message the ones you would like to meet. Searching is free.

Free to searchNo obligationID and DBS checkedYou choose the carer