This page is part of PrimeCarers' guide to dementia care.
Why it lands on you
Why she can be lovely to visitors and furious with you
When the GP says she seemed fine and the neighbour says she was a delight, it is easy to start believing the anger is about you. Look at the day from her side and a different picture appears.
One day in her week, and the part of it each person sees
Getting washed and dressed
The Alzheimer's Society says personal care can feel threatening, or like an invasion of personal space.
The morning tablets
Being handed something to swallow, by the person who is always telling her what to do.
Saying no
Not today to the shops alone, not the car keys, not another biscuit. Each one is a small loss of control.
The late afternoon
Dementia UK describes sundowning as intense confusion, anxiety and agitation around dusk, with irritability, shouting or arguing.
Getting ready for bed
Undressing again, the toilet, teeth. She is tired, and so are you.
The GP sees her for ten minutes, at a time she is dressed and ready, and asks her nothing she has to give up. A neighbour comes for a cup of tea. You are there for every task she would rather do herself and can no longer manage: being undressed, being handed tablets, being told she cannot go out alone. The Alzheimer's Society says that if a person has always valued their privacy and independence, being helped with eating or washing might make them angry. You are the person doing the helping.
You are also there for the hardest hours. Dementia UK describes sundowning as intense confusion, anxiety and agitation in the late afternoon and evening, and lists irritability, shouting and arguing among the signs. It also names family members being tired at that time of day as one of the things that can make it worse.
It may also matter that you are the person she is with when she is tired and has stopped making an effort. She may hold herself together for a short visit from somebody she wants to impress. With you, she may not feel she has to.
What can be behind it
Five things that can turn her anger towards you
The Alzheimer's Society says that when someone behaves in a challenging way, it is likely they are trying to stop feeling distressed, and the behaviour may be the best way they have of saying what they want. These are the reasons that point the distress at the person caring for her.
She is losing control, and you are the one taking itSection titled She%20is%20losing%20control%2C%20and%20you%20are%20the%20one%20taking%20it
Each thing you do for her is something she used to do herself. The Alzheimer's Society lists a sense of being out of control, and a feeling of not being listened to or understood, among the reasons behaviour changes. When you are the one holding the car keys and the pill box, the frustration has one obvious place to go.
She may not be sure who you areSection titled She%20may%20not%20be%20sure%20who%20you%20are
The Alzheimer's Society explains that a person may feel they are thirty years younger and not recognise a relative they expect to look younger too, and may accuse them of being someone else. It also describes people coming to believe that their partner is an impostor, which is known as Capgras syndrome. A stranger in her house helping her undress would frighten anyone. When someone with dementia does not recognise you explains the different reasons this happens and what to say.
She believes something that is not trueSection titled She%20believes%20something%20that%20is%20not%20true
Accusations of stealing are among the delusions the Alzheimer's Society describes, along with believing loved ones are trying to cause harm. It says delusions come from the person being unable to put pieces of information and memory together correctly, and that they feel as real to her as your reality feels to you. The person who moves her purse to a safe place is the obvious suspect when it goes missing.
It is the time of daySection titled It%20is%20the%20time%20of%20day
If the rows cluster in the late afternoon and evening, sundowning is a likely part of it, along with tiredness, hunger and thirst, which Dementia UK names among its causes.
Something hurts, or something is wrongSection titled Something%20hurts%2C%20or%20something%20is%20wrong
NICE guideline NG97 tells clinicians to look for the reasons behind distress in a person with dementia before any treatment, and to check for clinical or environmental causes, giving pain and delirium as examples. The Alzheimer's Society adds infection and constipation. A person who cannot say that her hip hurts may only be able to show it when somebody moves her, and that may well be you.
Calling out for help
Why she keeps calling out for help
Calling 'help me' over and over, when you are in the next room and nothing seems to be wrong, is one of the hardest things to listen to. The calling has causes, and when it happens is the best clue to which one.
When the calling happens, and what it may be telling you
When you leave the room
She may have lost track of where you are. The Alzheimer's Society says a person may keep calling out or asking for someone, because dementia makes people feel insecure and look for reassurance that they are not alone.
Try: Tell her where you are going before you go, and call back so she can hear your voice from the kitchen.
When it is new, or louder than it was
Dementia UK lists calling out, groaning or shouting as signs of pain, especially if the behaviour is new or has increased recently.
Try: Look for pain before anything else: a tooth, a hip, constipation, a sore spot. Tell the GP what you have noticed.
During washing, dressing or being moved
Dementia UK names seeming frightened or distressed during personal care as another sign of pain. It may also be fear of being handled.
Try: Say what you are about to do before you do it, and notice whether one arm or leg is the problem.
From late afternoon into the evening
This is the time of day Dementia UK links with sundowning. It names unmet needs such as hunger or thirst, pain and tiredness among the causes.
Try: A drink, a snack, the lights on before it gets dark, and the television off.
After a long time sitting with nothing to do
The Alzheimer's Society suggests asking whether the person is trying to tell you a need, for example that they are in pain, bored or thirsty.
Try: Something to do with her hands, the radio, or you doing a job in the same room.
Write down when it happens for a week or two, what came just before, and what settled it. The Alzheimer's Society suggests keeping a diary like this, and asking whether the behaviour always happens with the same person or in the same circumstances. A pattern you can show the GP is more useful than a description of a bad week, and if pain is part of it, how to tell whether someone with dementia is in pain sets out the signs to look for.
What to say
What to say when she turns on you
Arguing back, explaining or correcting her is unlikely to help: the Alzheimer's Society says that as dementia progresses, a person has more difficulty understanding logic and persuasion. What helps is answering the feeling and taking the pressure off.
She says
“Where is my purse? You have taken it.”
Instead of
“I have never touched your purse, Mum.”
Try
“That is horrible, thinking your purse has gone. Let's look for it together.”
The Alzheimer's Society says delusions feel as real to the person as your reality feels to you, and that you will not generally be able to convince them they are wrong. It also says not to dismiss an accusation without looking into it, because in some cases it may be true.
She says
“You are not my daughter. Get out of my house.”
Instead of
“Mum, it is me. Look at me.”
Try
“I am sorry, I did not mean to upset you. I will be in the kitchen if you want me.”
The Alzheimer's Society explains that a person may feel they are thirty years younger and not recognise a relative they expect to look younger too. Arguing does not shift it. Leaving the room gives the feeling a chance to pass.
She says
“I hate you. You are horrible to me.”
Instead of
“After everything I do for you.”
Try
“I can see this is difficult for you.”
That reply is the Alzheimer's Society's own example. It answers the feeling, which she may keep after she has forgotten the words.
She says
“Leave me alone. I do not need a wash.”
Instead of
“You have not had one since Tuesday.”
Try
“That is fine. I will put the kettle on.”
The Alzheimer's Society suggests asking whether a task needs doing right now, or whether it could be done later.
None of these replies will work every time. When nothing works, stop. The Alzheimer's Society suggests leaving the room until you are both feeling calmer, and says that if you do lose your temper, you should try not to feel guilty.
Your safety matters as much as hers. If she hits out or you feel unsafe, Dementia UK suggests going into another room you can lock, such as the bathroom, and agreeing a code word with family or friends that means you need help. It also says plainly that the reactions of a person with dementia can occasionally tip over into domestic abuse, and that it is essential to get help when they do. Ring 999 if you are at immediate risk. Aggression and agitation in dementia covers keeping yourself safe and what to tell the GP in more detail.
Handing over the hard jobs
Letting a carer do the washing and dressing
If most of the rows start at the same few tasks, it may help for somebody else to do those tasks. A carer from outside the family is sometimes accepted for washing and dressing when a daughter or son is refused.
Splitting the day: the jobs a carer can take, and the time that stays yours
A carer from outside the family
The tasks where the rows tend to start
The morning wash and getting dressed
Where a hard morning can begin, before either of you has had breakfast.
The toilet, pads and changing
The help a parent may find hardest to take from a son or daughter.
Prompting the tablets
A carer can prompt prescribed medicines as agreed and write down what was taken.
The late afternoon hour
Company, a drink and something to do at the time of day the agitation builds.
Getting ready for bed
Undressing, teeth and the toilet, so your last hour with her is not a struggle.
You
Being her daughter again
Tea and a chat
Time with her that asks nothing of her.
Photos, music and old stories
The things only family can share.
A walk or the garden
Going out together as her daughter, not her helper.
Appointments with the GP
Going with her, and telling the doctor what her days are like.
There are reasons this can work. Being undressed by your own child reverses a relationship that ran the other way for decades, and a carer does not carry that. A carer also arrives without the history of every difficult morning this month, and without the tiredness that is hard to keep out of your voice by the third attempt. The person who comes at the same time each day can become part of the routine. It will not always work. The Alzheimer's Society notes that a person being helped by somebody they do not know well may feel threatened and try to push them away, so give it a few weeks rather than judging it on the first visit.
On PrimeCarers you choose the carer yourself from their profile, meet them first, and agree the hours and the routine with them directly. You can keep the same person, which matters with dementia because a familiar face at a familiar time may be easier to accept. Every carer has their identity and right to work checked, an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and an online interview. Carers are insured while they work.
We do not check qualifications or dementia training, and you cannot search for carers by condition experience. What a profile says about dementia is the carer's own account, so ask at the interview what they do when somebody refuses a wash, or turns on them. Tell them what has been happening, including the accusations and the time of day it is worst: the client contract asks you to give the carer full information in advance about known risks, including cognitive impairment and challenging behaviours. When you are ready, you can search for hourly carers near your mum and compare their rates and reviews.
Looking after yourself
Looking after yourself while this is happening
The Alzheimer's Society says it is important not to take the behaviour personally, and also that every carer will need help as dementia progresses. Being the target of a parent's anger day after day wears anybody down, and asking for help is part of caring for her.
Ask the council for a carer's assessment. The NHS says anyone over 18 who looks after someone can ask for one, that it is free, and that it can lead to help such as someone to take over the caring so you can have a break. Carers UK adds that it does not matter how much or what sort of care you provide. NICE guideline NG97 tells professionals to tell carers of people with dementia about their right to an assessment, so you can raise it with the GP or memory service too. What is a carer's assessment explains what happens at one.
Talk to someone who understands dementia. The Admiral Nurse Dementia Helpline, run by Dementia UK on 0800 888 6678, is staffed by specialist dementia nurses, and the Alzheimer's Society's Dementia Support Line is on 0333 150 3456. Carers UK's helpline on 0808 808 7777 covers carers' assessments, benefits and your rights as a carer.
If you can, tell the rest of the family what is happening. A brother who only hears Mum on the phone may not know what your days are like, and an hour of his time on a Saturday is a break for you.
Questions
Questions about a parent with dementia who turns on you
Because you are there for the parts of her day that are hardest for her: washing, dressing, tablets, being told no, and the late afternoon, when sundowning can bring irritability and shouting. Visitors see her briefly, with nothing asked of her. The Alzheimer's Society says a person with dementia is not likely to be behaving aggressively on purpose.
The feeling is real to her in the moment. The Alzheimer's Society says the person is likely to be trying to stop feeling distressed, and advises not taking it personally.
She may not remember what was said, but the Alzheimer's Society says a person who forgets an event can still feel the emotions of it later. That is why ending a hard moment calmly matters more than winning it, and why there is no need to go back over it afterwards.
The Alzheimer's Society says a person with dementia may keep calling out or asking for someone because they feel insecure and want reassurance they are not alone. Dementia UK lists calling out, groaning or shouting as possible signs of pain, especially when they are new or getting worse. Note when it happens and tell the GP if you think she may be in pain.
If washing and dressing is where most of the rows start, it is worth trying a carer from outside the family for those tasks. Some people accept help from a carer that they refuse from a son or daughter. When someone with dementia refuses care goes into washing, food and medication refusals in more detail.
Dementia UK's Admiral Nurse Dementia Helpline (0800 888 6678), the Alzheimer's Society's Dementia Support Line (0333 150 3456) and Carers UK (0808 808 7777) all take calls from family carers. Admiral Nurses and free dementia support explains what each one offers and how to reach them.
