Who makes the decision
Responsibility goes one decision at a time, not all at once
There is no single person who becomes responsible for someone with dementia. The law asks who can make this particular decision, today, and the answer can be different for paying a bill and for agreeing to a carer.
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 starts from the position that your relative can decide for themselves, and that nobody should treat them as unable to decide until everything practical has been done to help them. A dementia diagnosis does not change that on its own. Section 2 says a person lacks capacity for a matter at the time the decision has to be made, so your mother may be able to choose what to eat and whether she wants help with washing, while no longer being able to follow a letter from the bank.
An unwise choice is not proof that capacity has gone either. If your father can understand the risks of staying in his own home, weigh them and tell you what he wants, the decision is his, even if it worries you. When a decision is beyond him, the law gives it to someone else in a fixed order.
For any one decision, start at the top
Stop at the first rung that applies. Different decisions can stop at different rungs in the same week.
Your relative
If they can make this decision, with help if they need it
Capacity is judged one decision at a time, at the time it needs making. A diagnosis does not remove it, and an unwise choice is not proof that it has gone. Explain things simply, at their best time of day, before deciding they cannot.
Mental Capacity Act 2005, sections 1 and 2
If not
An attorney
If there is a registered lasting power of attorney that covers this kind of decision
A property and financial affairs LPA covers money, bills and property, and can be used with your relative’s permission while they can still decide. A health and welfare LPA covers care and treatment, and can only be used once they cannot decide for themselves.
gov.uk, Lasting power of attorney
If not
A deputy
If the Court of Protection has appointed one and the order covers this decision
Where there is no LPA, the court can appoint a deputy for money and property, and less commonly for welfare. The court order says what the deputy can and cannot do.
gov.uk, Become a deputy
If not
Whoever is responsible at the time
If none of the above applies
For day-to-day care, that is the carer most directly involved, family or paid. For treatment, it is the doctor or nurse who would carry it out. They must act in your relative’s best interests, take account of their wishes and beliefs, and listen to the family.
Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 4, and Code of Practice paragraph 5.8
If the people involved cannot agree
The Court of Protection makes decisions on money and welfare for people who cannot make them at the time they need to be made. Concerns about how an attorney or deputy is behaving go to the Office of the Public Guardian.
Being next of kin does not appear anywhere on that ladder. The NHS says that without a lasting power of attorney or another appointed decision-maker, the healthcare professionals treating your relative make treatment decisions, taking account of what close family can tell them about your relative's wishes. So as next of kin you are asked for your view, and the decision stays with the doctor. For more on the duties you take on when you are that carer at the time, read your duty of care when you are looking after a parent.
If there is no LPA
What happens when nobody has a lasting power of attorney
The bank will not talk to you, the bills are piling up, and your relative can no longer sign anything. Here is what to check, in order.
The first thing to do is look for one. Ask your relative, look through their papers, and ask the Office of the Public Guardian, which registers lasting powers of attorney in England and Wales: its form OPG100 asks it to search the register for you. An enduring power of attorney made and signed before 1 October 2007 can also still be used, once it is registered.
If there is none, the next question is whether your relative can still make one. A lasting power of attorney is something they sign themselves, so it only needs them to have capacity for that one decision, which they may have even if they cannot run their finances day to day. Lasting power of attorney and dementia explains the two kinds, who signs what, and how the certificate provider checks they understand.
If it is too late for that, the routes split by the kind of decision.
Money and propertySection titled Money%20and%20property
Somebody, such as a family member, applies to the Court of Protection to be appointed as a property and financial affairs deputy. Until the court order arrives, nobody has authority over your relative's bank accounts or property. If the only thing that needs managing is their benefits, the Department for Work and Pensions can appoint someone as their benefits appointee without going to court. The Court of Protection guide sets out the application, the fees and what a deputy has to report each year.
Care and treatmentSection titled Care%20and%20treatment
Here the law does not leave a gap. The people looking after your relative make care decisions in their best interests under section 4 of the Act, and they must take into account the views of anyone caring for your relative or interested in their welfare. For a decision such as a move into a care home, that is the social worker or care team arranging it, and they must consult you. gov.uk says the court usually appoints a welfare deputy only where there is doubt about what is in someone's best interests, such as a family disagreement.
The forms for lasting powers of attorney and deputyship are on gov.uk and can be completed without a solicitor, and the Office of the Public Guardian can explain the process. A solicitor is worth considering when there is property, a business or a family dispute.
Who has a duty to act
What the council, the NHS and the family each have to do
Deciding is one kind of responsibility. Having to act is another, and the law puts most of it on public bodies rather than on relatives.
What they must do
Where the duty comes from
The council
Adult social care, where your relative lives
Assess your relative’s care needs when it appears they may need care and support, whatever their savings or income.
Care Act 2014, s9
Assess you as their carer if it appears you may need support.
Care Act 2014, s10
Make enquiries when it has reason to suspect abuse or neglect of an adult who cannot protect themselves.
Care Act 2014, s42
The NHS
The GP, the memory service and the integrated care board
The GP rules out other causes, refers to a specialist or memory clinic, and should see your relative from time to time after a diagnosis.
nhs.uk, Diagnosing dementia
The integrated care board assesses for NHS continuing healthcare and arranges and funds it if your relative is eligible. Eligibility depends on assessed needs, not on a diagnosis.
nhs.uk, NHS continuing healthcare
The family
Children, spouse, brothers and sisters
No law makes a son or daughter provide care, and the council’s financial assessment looks at your relative’s money, not yours.
Care Act 2014, s17
Once you have the care of someone who lacks capacity, ill-treating or wilfully neglecting them is a crime.
Mental Capacity Act 2005, s44
Acting for them in their best interests, after reasonable steps to check they cannot decide, is protected unless it is done negligently.
Mental Capacity Act 2005, s5
Your relative, as a driver
If they hold a driving licence
Tell the DVLA about the dementia. The duty is the driver’s, and gov.uk says they can be fined up to £1,000 for not reporting a condition that affects driving.
gov.uk, Dementia and driving
The family row answers what you have to do yourself. You are not breaking the law by living far away, by not giving up work to care, or by deciding that you cannot do the personal care yourself.
The duty changes once you take on the care of someone who lacks capacity. Section 44 applies to anyone who has the care of such a person, and to their attorneys and deputies, and makes ill-treatment or wilful neglect a criminal offence. If you are caring and you can no longer keep your relative safe, telling adult social care that you cannot cope is the responsible step, and it starts the assessments in the table above.
Driving is different, because the law puts that duty on your relative. gov.uk says the driver must tell the DVLA about a dementia diagnosis. Dementia and driving sets out how to do it together and what to do if they will not.
Who pays for care
Who pays for care for someone with dementia
The person who pays is your relative, the council or the NHS. Their children are not on that list.
- Check first
NHS continuing healthcare
Ask whether your relative should be screened. If they are eligible, the NHS arranges and pays for the care, at home or in a care home, and it is not means-tested.
- Check next
The council, after two assessments
The needs assessment decides what care is needed. A financial assessment then looks at your relative’s own income and savings to work out what they pay and what the council pays.
- Check then
Your relative’s own money
Whatever they pay comes from their money, not yours. Their attorney or deputy pays the bills from it once they cannot.
The family. Family money comes in only if somebody chooses to pay, for example a top-up for a care home that costs more than the council will pay.
Under section 17 of the Care Act 2014, the council's financial assessment looks at the resources of the adult who needs care, not at the income of their children. NHS continuing healthcare is arranged and funded by the local integrated care board, and the NHS says eligibility depends on assessed needs, not on any particular diagnosis, so a diagnosis of dementia does not settle the question either way. Do I have to pay for my parent's care? goes through the rules in each part of the UK.
Once your relative cannot manage money, the attorney or deputy is the person who signs for care and pays for it from your relative's own money. That includes paying a carer at home. When you know who decides and who pays, the next step is to arrange the care that fits: you can search for carers near your relative, read their profiles and meet the ones you like before anything is agreed. On PrimeCarers the family, or the attorney, chooses the carer and agrees the hours and routine with them directly.
Who to contact first
When something has gone wrong, who to contact first
A fall, a scam or a disagreement between brothers and sisters can be what makes a family ask who is responsible. This is where each one goes first.
What has happened
Who to contact first
A fall, a hospital stay, or signs they are not managing at home
Adult social care at their council, for a care needs assessment. Tell the GP as well.
Money going missing, a scam, or somebody taking advantage
Their bank, then the council’s adult safeguarding team. Ring 999 if they are in danger now.
An attorney or deputy misusing money or ignoring their wishes
The Office of the Public Guardian, which investigates attorneys and deputies.
Bills unpaid and nobody can sign for them
Check for a registered LPA. If there is none and your relative cannot make one, a deputyship application to the Court of Protection.
The family disagrees about care or where they should live
Ask the social worker or the doctor making the decision for a best-interests meeting. The Court of Protection decides if it cannot be settled.
Still driving after the diagnosis
Your relative tells the DVLA. If they will not, talk to the GP.
Money being taken and signs of neglect both go to adult social care, because of its safeguarding duty. Under section 42 of the Care Act 2014 the council must make enquiries when it has reason to suspect that an adult with care needs is being abused or neglected and cannot protect themselves, and that includes money being taken. You do not need proof before you ring; your part is to raise the concern. Safeguarding adults and how to report explains what happens after the call.
Questions
Questions families ask about who is responsible
Not to make decisions. Next of kin is not a legal role under the Mental Capacity Act 2005. Close family have a right to be consulted when a best-interests decision is made, because section 4 requires the decision-maker to take account of the views of anyone caring for the person or interested in their welfare. Authority to decide comes only from a registered lasting power of attorney or a court order.
No. No law in England makes an adult child provide care for a parent. If you do take on her care and she lacks capacity, you must not ill-treat or wilfully neglect her, and if you cannot keep caring safely, the council has to assess her needs.
The same people as for anyone else: the person themselves for decisions they can make, then the carers, doctors and social workers involved, acting in their best interests. The NHS says that where there is nobody suitable to consult about a serious decision, an independent mental capacity advocate must be involved to speak for them.
Not of their money or their life in general. The council must assess care needs, make safeguarding enquiries and, with the care team, make care decisions in the person's best interests when they cannot. Control of money needs a lasting power of attorney, a deputyship order from the Court of Protection, or a benefits appointeeship from the DWP.
Your relative, if they can understand and weigh the decision. If they cannot, a health and welfare attorney or a welfare deputy decides, and otherwise the professionals arranging the care decide in their best interests after consulting the family. Can someone be forced into a care home? goes into this decision in detail.
