Talking to herself
Talking to yourself is not a symptom on its own
Before you look for a cause, it helps to know that hearing your mother talk to herself does not, by itself, tell you anything is wrong.
People talk to themselves to plan, to remember, to calm down and to keep themselves company. Your mother may run through the shopping list as she writes it, tell the kettle to hurry up, or argue with the news on the radio. None of that appears on the NHS list of early signs of dementia, which is about memory, finding words, following conversations and getting confused about the date or place.
Living alone changes how much of this you hear. Someone who shared a house for fifty years was used to saying her thoughts to another person. When that person is gone, the thoughts are still said out loud, only now to the room, a photo or the cat. She may talk to your father this way, and there is nothing wrong with that. If she is still cooking, going out, keeping up with friends and following your conversations without trouble, it is most likely a habit, and it is kinder to leave it alone than to make her self-conscious about it.
What is worth noticing is a change: talk that has become more constant, more worried or harder to follow, or that started recently.
Talking non-stop
Why she talks without stopping when you visit
The other common worry is the opposite: she does not talk to herself, she talks at you, from the moment you arrive until you leave.
If your mother lives alone, the hour you are there may be most of the conversation she has that week. Everything that has happened since your last visit, every small thought and every piece of news, has been waiting for somebody to hear it. That can come out as a flood of talk that barely lets you answer, and it can be tiring and frustrating for you, especially if you are trying to sort out bills or appointments in the same visit.
The useful clue is whether it eases. A mother who talks without stopping for the first hour and then settles into a normal back and forth is probably telling you that her days are too quiet. That is a reason to count how many conversations she has in a week, rather than a reason to see a doctor. Helping someone who is lonely covers the free and paid ways to fill those days.
If the talk does not ease, goes round in the same few worries, or is hard to follow, look at the patterns below.
What the talk points to
Match what you hear to where it points
The words themselves are the best clue. Listen for what she says, whether it makes sense, and what else goes with it.
What the talk sounds like, and where each kind points
From the everyday at the top to the urgent at the bottom. Find the one closest to what you hear.
Right, keys, purse, then the bins. Now where did I put my glasses?
A running commentary while she moves about the house, or talking to the cat, the radio or a photo.
Where it points
Thinking aloud. People do it at every age, and someone who spent years talking things through with a husband may simply carry on out loud.
Nothing to treat
Talk starts the moment you are through the door and hardly pauses for the first hour.
News, stories and small things saved up since the last time anyone came, easing off as the visit goes on.
Where it points
Days with little or no conversation. The talk has nowhere to go until someone arrives.
More company, spread through the week
She answers a question you did not ask, or talks over you, with the television loud.
Asking people to repeat themselves, struggling on the phone, and mishearing what people say, especially somewhere noisy.
Where it points
Hearing loss. These are among the signs the NHS lists, and it says other people may notice them before she does.
Ask the GP about a hearing test
Going over the same worries out loud: the bill, the boiler, whether the door is locked.
Restless, unsettled, finding it hard to stop, and sleeping badly.
Where it points
Anxiety or low mood. Saying the worry out loud is one way people try to settle it.
Ask the GP
Pass me the thing you sit on. And then she went... no, where was I?
Losing words, swapping in the wrong ones, jumbled order, or jumping between topics without finishing. It has crept in over months.
Where it points
Possibly dementia, among other causes. The Alzheimer's Society describes these changes, and the NHS lists trouble finding words and following conversations among early signs.
See the GP soon
Muddled, slurred or nonsense speech that was not there yesterday.
It came on over hours or a day or two. She may be drowsy, agitated, or different from one hour to the next.
Where it points
A stroke or sudden confusion (delirium), which the NHS says can come from an infection such as a urine infection, a stroke, low blood sugar or some medicines.
Call 999
Several of these can be true at once. The NHS says straining to listen can be tiring and stressful, so a mother who struggles to hear may also start to see fewer people. Worry can sit alongside early memory changes. You do not have to decide which one it is; the GP can, and what you have heard is the most useful thing you can bring.
If she also repeats the same story or question, that is a separate pattern with its own causes. When an elderly mother keeps repeating herself goes through that in detail.
When it is urgent
New muddled or nonsense speech that came on quickly needs help today
Speed is what separates an emergency from a GP appointment. A change that came on over months can wait a few days for the doctor. A change that came on since yesterday cannot.
How quickly did the change in her speech come on?
Within minutes or hours
Slurred or confused speech, or trouble finding words, perhaps with one side of the face drooping or one arm weak.
Call 999
NHS: stroke symptoms. Call even if the signs have stopped.
Over a day or two
She has suddenly become confused, cannot think or speak clearly, and may be better one hour and worse the next.
A&E or 999
NHS: go to A&E or call 999 if someone suddenly becomes confused.
Slowly, over months
Gradually more forgetful or muddled, losing words, or losing the thread of a conversation.
Book a GP appointment
NHS: see a GP if someone has gradually become more forgetful or confused.
The NHS lists speech problems, such as slurred words or sounding confused, among the main signs of a stroke, with face weakness and arm weakness, and says to call 999 if you think someone is having a stroke, even if the signs have gone. Sudden confusion, which doctors call delirium, has many causes, from a stroke or low blood sugar to some prescription medicines. If she lives with dementia, this is harder to spot, because some of the signs are the same. The question to ask yourself is whether she is different today from how she normally is. If she is, treat it as new.
The NHS names urine infections as a common cause of sudden confusion in older people, and UTIs and sudden confusion explains what to watch for if she has had them before.
Raising it with the GP
Telling the GP what you have heard
If the change has come on slowly, a GP appointment is the right next step, and it will be more useful if you go in with notes rather than a general worry.
Over a week or two, write down what you notice. Short notes are enough. The things a GP will want to know are:
- what she says, in her own words if you can, and whether it makes sense
- when it happens: all day, in the evening, only when she is alone, or only when someone visits
- when you first noticed it, and whether it came on slowly or suddenly
- whether she mishears, has the television loud or struggles on the phone
- whether she seems worried, low, or is sleeping or eating differently
- any new medicines, a recent fall, or a recent infection
Go with her if she is happy for you to, or write to the surgery before the appointment with what you have noticed. Hearing is a simple place to start: the NHS says a GP can look for causes such as earwax or an infection and refer her to a hearing specialist, and the hearing charity RNID says the GP is the way to a free NHS hearing test and, if she needs them, free NHS hearing aids. If you are worried about her memory or words, the NHS advice is to talk to a GP sooner rather than later. It also says dementia is not a natural part of ageing, so it is not something to put down to her age.
If her talk is mostly worry, or she seems low and withdrawn, say so plainly. Anxiety and low mood can change how someone talks and behaves, and the GP can help with both. Mental health in later life covers what the GP can offer.
Whether company would help
Whether regular company would change it
If the pattern you recognise is the flood of talk on visit days, what helps is fewer silent days in her week, more than a longer visit.
Minutes of conversation in an example week for a mother living alone
- A few words in passing
- You, on the phone or visiting
- A companion visit
As things are
2.7 hours of talk, 2 silent days
- Mon5m
- Tue15m
- Wednone
- Thu5m
- Fri15m
- Sat120m
- Sunnone
With a companion three mornings a week
5.7 hours of talk, 1 silent day
- Mon65m
- Tue15m
- Wed60m
- Thu5m
- Fri75m
- Sat120m
- Sunnone
In the example, a long Saturday visit and two phone calls are most of her week. Two more days have a few words in passing, and two have none at all. Three one-hour visits from someone she gets to know spread conversation through the week, so Saturday does not have to carry all of it. Count her own week the same way, and look at the gaps. Family, friends, a lunch club or a befriending call may fill some of them.
Where nobody can cover a gap, a companionship carer can. The visit is time spent with her: a chat over tea, a walk to the shops, an old hobby, a trip out. A carer who sees her several times a week will also get to know how she normally talks, and can tell you if something changes, or ring 111 or 999 if something is wrong while they are there. A carer does not diagnose or give medical advice; that stays with the GP.
PrimeCarers is an introductory service, not a care agency. You and your mother choose the carer, meet them first, and agree the days and what the visits are for directly with them, and you can keep the same person. Every carer has had their identity and right to work checked, has an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and has had an online interview. Carers are insured while they work.
Carers offering companionship on PrimeCarers charge £15 to £20 an hour, with our fee included, so three one-hour visits a week come to £45 to £60. What a companion carer costs sets out the range in more detail.
Questions
Questions families ask
For the same reasons anyone does: to think through a task, remember a list, calm themselves or keep themselves company. People who live alone after years with a partner may do it more, simply because there is nobody else in the room. On its own it is not a sign of illness. A change in how she talks, such as lost or jumbled words, constant worry or new confusion, is what is worth acting on.
Not on its own. The early signs of dementia the NHS lists are about memory, concentration, finding the right word, following a conversation and knowing the date or place. If your mother talks to herself but follows conversations normally and manages her day, that is not one of them. If the words themselves are getting lost or muddled, see the GP.
Listen for the feeling behind the words rather than correcting the facts, because the talk may be how she is expressing worry, boredom or discomfort. Keep your own sentences short and give her time to answer. How to talk to someone with dementia has more on this. If the talking is new or much worse than usual, check for something new, such as pain or an infection.
Treat it as urgent. The NHS says to go to A&E or call 999 if someone suddenly becomes confused, and to call 999 for slurred or confused speech that could be a stroke, even if it passes. Do not wait to see if it settles.
It can go with the same causes. Drifting off in the middle of a conversation can come from tiredness, hearing loss that makes talk hard to follow, low mood or memory changes, and it is worth mentioning to the GP alongside anything you have noticed about her talk. If she has suddenly become confused, the NHS says to go to A&E or call 999.
If it is the everyday kind, there is no need, and pointing it out can make her self-conscious in her own home. If you are worried, talk about the thing that worries you instead, such as missing words on the phone or a television that is very loud, and suggest the GP as a check rather than a verdict.
