PrimeCarers

Elderly careMemory

My elderly mother keeps repeating herself: is it dementia?

Not necessarily, but some kinds of repeating are worth taking to her GP. Telling an old favourite story again, or losing a word and finding it a minute later, comes with age; retelling something from this week within minutes, asking again for what she was just told, or forgetting that a conversation happened is the kind to mention. Hearing loss, worry, low mood, a medicine, the thyroid and low vitamin B12 can all look like this, and the GP checks for them first. This page sets the two kinds of repeating side by side, then covers what to write down, how to raise it without a row, and how to answer her in the meantime.

By , founder of PrimeCarers  ·  Updated  ·  13 min read · Compare two phone calls

Part of our guide to elderly care.

Age or something more

The repeating that comes with age, and the kind to tell her GP about

Alzheimer's Society says people tend to forget things more as they get older. The difference it draws is between forgetting something told a while ago and forgetting something told only recently, and between occasional forgetting and the kind that gets in the way of everyday life.

A call that sounds like getting older

  1. 6.02pm

    MumI saw her at church, the one with the spaniel. Oh, what is her name? Pat. Pat Ellis.

    A name that takes a moment to come, then comes back by itself.

  2. 6.07pm

    MumI know I have told you this one before, but the day your dad got lost in Whitby...

    An old favourite story, and she knows she is repeating it.

  3. 6.11pm

    MumHang on, where did I put my glasses? I had them in the kitchen. Here they are.

    Mislaid, then found by retracing her steps.

The next Sunday

“How did the lunch with your friends go? You were looking forward to it.”

A call worth describing to her GP

  1. 6.02pm

    MumMichael came round on Tuesday and fixed the side gate.

  2. 6.05pm

    YouWe will come for lunch on Saturday, about twelve.

  3. 6.14pm

    MumDid I tell you Michael came round on Tuesday and fixed the side gate?

    Something from this week, told again minutes later, with no sign she remembers telling it.

  4. 6.16pm

    MumAre you coming over at the weekend?

    Asking for something she was told ten minutes ago.

The next Sunday

“You did not ring last week. I was waiting all evening.”

Drawn from the Alzheimer's Society comparison of common signs of ageing and possible signs of dementia, and the NHS list of early symptoms. The lines are examples, not a test: only a doctor can say what is causing a change.

Hold your own Sunday call up against these two. On the left, the memory is slower but it is all there: the name comes back, she knows the Whitby story is a repeat, and she remembers last week's conversation. Alzheimer's Society lists forgetting where you put something but retracing your steps to find it, and occasionally struggling to find the right word when there are distractions, as common signs of ageing.

On the right, the new information has not stuck. Alzheimer's Society gives "forgetting something you were only recently told" and asking for the same information again and again as possible signs of dementia, and the NHS lists regularly forgetting recent events and asking questions repetitively among the common symptoms of Alzheimer's disease. One call like this on a tired evening means little. The same pattern over several weeks, or a change you can date ("she was not like this at Easter"), is the point to involve the GP.

Alzheimer's Society also says dementia is different from ordinary ageing because the change is noticeable over months rather than gradual over many years, and because everyday tasks become harder to manage alone. So look beyond the calls as well: bills, shopping, appointments and meals. If those are slipping too, say so to the GP. The elderly care guides cover the other changes in an older parent that are worth noticing.

Other causes

Other things that make someone repeat themselves

Repeating herself does not have to mean her memory is failing. The NHS says memory is affected by stress, tiredness, certain illnesses and medicines, and NICE asks GPs to rule out treatable causes, including depression, hearing and sight loss and some medicines, before referring anyone for a dementia assessment.

  • She says "pardon" a lot, answers a slightly different question, or has the television louder than she used to.

    Hearing loss

    GP, or a hearing test

    Alzheimer's Society explains that something not heard properly is never stored, so it looks like forgetting. The NHS lists asking people to repeat themselves and difficulty hearing on the phone as signs of hearing loss.

  • The same worry comes back again and again: the back door, a bill, the boiler.

    Anxiety or stress

    GP

    The NHS and Alzheimer's Society both name stress and anxiety as causes of memory problems. In its advice on repetition, Alzheimer's Society says a repeated question can come from feeling anxious, and calls for reassurance more than a fact.

  • She seems flat or tired, has dropped things she used to enjoy, or says she is not sleeping.

    Low mood or poor sleep

    GP

    The NHS names depression and sleeping problems among the common causes of memory loss that can be treated.

  • She is more tired, slower or foggier than she was, and it has crept up over months.

    Thyroid or vitamin B12

    GP blood test

    The NHS lists difficulty thinking clearly among the symptoms of an underactive thyroid, and problems with memory, understanding and judgement among the symptoms of low B12 or folate.

  • It started around the time of a new tablet or a change of dose.

    A medicine

    GP or pharmacist

    Alzheimer's Society says some medicines can affect thinking and memory, and suggests checking the leaflet and asking a GP or pharmacist. Do not stop or change anything without asking them.

  • Her memory has slipped for a few months, but she still manages her day, her money and her house.

    Mild cognitive impairment

    GP, then perhaps a memory service

    Alzheimer's Society describes this as memory or thinking problems that do not stop everyday tasks. The NHS says it stays the same for some people and goes on to dementia for others.

  • It came on over hours or a day or two, and she is muddled, drowsy or not herself.

    Sudden confusion (delirium)

    A&E or 999

    The NHS says to go to A&E or call 999 if someone suddenly becomes confused. An infection is a common cause in older people.

Sources: Alzheimer's Society, causes of memory problems and mild cognitive impairment; NHS pages on memory loss, hearing loss, underactive thyroid, vitamin B12 deficiency and sudden confusion; NICE NG97, recommendation 1.2.6.

Hearing is worth thinking about first, because it is the easiest to miss on the phone. If she did not hear your answer properly, she never stored it, and asking again is the natural thing to do. A hearing test is simple to arrange, and the guide to hearing loss and care at home covers what helps once one is done.

Mild cognitive impairment sits between ordinary ageing and dementia. Alzheimer's Society says it can be caused by other health problems, such as sleep disorders or the side effects of medicines, so it is still worth the GP knowing: they can look for those causes and keep an eye on any change.

Getting her to the GP

What to write down, and how to suggest the GP without a row

The GP will ask what has changed, when it started and how it affects her day. NICE asks GPs to take that history from the person and, where possible, from someone who knows them well. Two weeks of short, dated notes give you something specific to say.

Mum: what I have noticed

An example of two weeks of notes, written as they happen

  1. Sun 2 Nov

    Phone

    Told me Michael fixed the gate, then told me again about ten minutes later as if it was new.

  2. Tue 4 Nov

    Phone

    Asked twice if we were coming on Saturday. I had told her on Sunday and it is on her calendar.

  3. Thu 6 Nov

    Neighbour

    Pat says Mum asked her two times in one visit whether the bins had gone out.

  4. Sat 8 Nov

    Visit

    Two loaves and three pints of milk in the fridge, bought on different days. She did not know why.

  5. Sun 9 Nov

    Phone

    Did not remember last Sunday's call at all.

When it started

Noticed in the summer, more since September.

Hearing and sight

Television is loud. Last hearing test: not sure.

Mood and sleep

Says she is sleeping badly. Not going to the lunch club any more.

Medicines

Copy every name and dose from the boxes, including anything bought from the chemist.

NICE guideline NG97 asks the GP to take a history from the person and, where possible, from someone who knows them well, including how the changes affect daily life (recommendation 1.2.1).

Write down what she said or did, the date, and whether it was on the phone, on a visit or from someone else. One clear example is worth more than "she keeps forgetting things". Include how it affects her day, such as shopping bought twice or a bill paid late, and anything about hearing, mood, sleep and medicines, because those are what the GP will check first.

When you raise it with her, Alzheimer's Society suggests a familiar, quiet place, a time when neither of you is rushed, and reassuring words that do not judge. You could start by asking whether she has noticed anything different herself, then mention one or two of your examples, and say you are raising it because you care. There is no need to use the word dementia before a doctor has. Suggesting a general check-up, or tying it to something she does want help with, such as poor sleep or her hearing, may make it easier for her to agree. Offer to book it and go with her. The same approach works for other hard conversations, and how to talk to a parent about getting help goes through it step by step.

At the appointment the GP will usually do a physical check, blood and urine tests, and a short memory test. NICE says a normal score on that short test should not on its own rule dementia out, which is one more reason your notes matter. If the GP finds no other cause and is still concerned, NICE says they should refer her to a specialist service such as a memory clinic. Getting a dementia diagnosis follows that route in detail, including what to do if she will not go.

If she refuses and you are still worried, you can write to or ring the GP yourself. Alzheimer's Society explains that confidentiality stops a GP giving out information about a patient, but not receiving it, and it is up to the GP how to act on it. Your notes are what to send.

Answering the repeats

How to answer when she says it again

Alzheimer's Society says a person who repeats a question is very unlikely to know they are doing it, and that the question often needs comfort or reassurance more than the answer. That advice is written about dementia, and it is a kind way to answer a repeat whatever the cause turns out to be.

  1. MumDid I tell you Michael fixed the gate?

    Rather thanYou told me ten minutes ago.

    TryYou did, and I am glad. How did he get it to shut properly in the end?

    Pointing out the repeat does not help her remember it. Answering it as a conversation keeps her talking and keeps the call warm.

  2. MumDid I pay the gas bill?

    Rather thanYes, Mum, I keep telling you.

    TryIt is paid. It goes out by direct debit, and I have written that on the note by the phone.

    A worry that keeps returning needs the reassurance as much as the fact. Writing it down gives her something to check when you are not there.

  3. MumAre you coming at the weekend?

    Rather thanI already said Saturday.

    TryYes, Saturday at twelve. Is it on the calendar by the kettle?

    Alzheimer's Society suggests a calendar or clock where it is easy to see, so the answer is there between calls.

  4. MumI am getting so forgetful these days.

    Rather thanOh, we all do that.

    TryWhat have you noticed? It might be worth asking the doctor, and I could come with you.

    When she raises it herself, that is the easiest moment to talk about the GP. Brushing it off closes the door.

Built on Alzheimer's Society advice on repetition: keep your tone calm, think about the need behind the question, and put the answer where she can see it.

Keep your voice level, even on the third time round. Correcting her ("you said that already") does not help her remember, and it can make her anxious about calls she used to enjoy. Notice whether the repeats come at a particular time, such as late in the day or when she is tired, and whether one subject keeps coming back. A worry that returns again and again, about money, the house or a family member, may be the thing to sort out first.

If you have also noticed her chatting away when she is on her own, that is a separate question, and why an elderly parent talks to themselves covers when it is ordinary and when to mention it.

Between your calls

If she is on her own most of the week

A weekly phone call shows you one hour of her week. If she lives alone and you are some way away, regular company in person helps her and gives you a second pair of eyes.

A companion carer can come for a few hours on set days to sit with her over lunch, walk to the shops with her and go with her to the GP or the hearing test. Over a few weeks they get to know her, so they notice when something changes and can tell you, and you have someone else's examples to add to your notes. They do not give medical advice or replace the GP; their part is the company and the help around the house.

On PrimeCarers you can search for carers near her and read their profiles. You choose the person, meet them first and agree the days and hours with them directly. Every carer's identity and right to work are checked, they have an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and they are interviewed online. Carers are insured while they work. Companion carers on PrimeCarers charge £15 to £20 an hour with our fee included.

Questions

Questions families ask about a parent repeating themselves

It can be, but on its own it is not enough to say. Telling an old story again, or asking again because you did not hear, is common. Asking repeatedly for something you were only recently told, or forgetting recent conversations, is listed by Alzheimer's Society and the NHS among the possible signs. Only a doctor can say what is causing it, and the GP is the place to start.

Forgetting recent conversations can come from stress, poor sleep, low mood, an infection, a medicine or dementia, among other causes. If she also struggles to hear on the phone, she may not have taken the conversation in at all. Note a few examples with dates and take them to her GP.

Pointing out each repeat in the moment does not help her remember and can upset her. It is better to raise the bigger worry once, calmly and in private, with one or two examples, and to suggest a check-up with the GP that you offer to go to with her.

Yes. Alzheimer's Society explains that a GP cannot give out information about a patient without their agreement, but can receive it. Write a short letter or ring the surgery with your dated examples and ask for it to go on her notes. The GP will decide how to act on it.

Confusion that appears over hours or a day or two is different from a slow change. The NHS says to go to A&E or call 999 if someone suddenly becomes confused, and lists infection among the causes. UTIs and sudden confusion explains one common cause in older people.

Would some company in the week help her?

Look at companion carers near your mother, read their profiles and rates, and message the ones you like. You choose who to meet.

Free to searchNo obligationID and DBS checkedYou choose the carer