PrimeCarers

Elderly careTalk

My parent refuses to go to hospital or see a doctor

If your parent can understand and weigh up the decision, nobody can make them go, and that includes you. You can still ring 999 if their life may be in danger, whatever they say, and the ambulance crew will then judge whether they are able to refuse. Short of an emergency, a doctor may be able to see them at home, and you may be able to take away the parts of the trip they dread.

Find someone to go with your parent and bring them home

If the journey, the wait or coming back to an empty house is the reason for the no, search for a carer near your parent who can travel with them, sit with them through the appointment and stay until they are settled at home.

Free to search. Compare profiles, rates and reviews, then discuss the help you need with the carer.

By , founder of PrimeCarers  ·  Updated  ·  13 min read · When to ring 999 anyway

Part of our guide to elderly care.

Before anything else

When to ring 999, even if your parent says no

Ringing 999 does not force your parent into an ambulance. It brings people who can examine them and who are trained to judge whether they can make the decision to refuse.

The NHS says 999 is for life-threatening emergencies, and gives strokes and heart attacks as examples. It also says to call 999 or go to A&E if someone suddenly becomes confused, because many causes of sudden confusion need to be assessed and treated as soon as possible. In older people one common cause is an infection. If you are not sure whether it is an emergency, NHS 111 can tell you what to do, online or on the phone.

If your parent's life may be at risk, ring. You do not need their permission, and it is not a betrayal of them. What happens next is in the hands of the crew, and it follows the law on capacity rather than what either of you says on the doorstep.

  1. You ring 999

    Tell the call handler what you can see and that your parent is refusing to go. While you wait, the NHS asks you to lock pets away, gather their medicines and have their GP's details ready.

  2. The crew talks to your parent and examines them

    A health professional who proposes treatment has to check that the person can consent to it. That check is the crew's job, not yours.

Can your parent make this decision right now?

Yes

If your parent can make this decision

They can still say no, and the crew cannot take them against their will. The crew will explain the risks to them. Ask the crew what to watch for and who to ring if things change.

No

If they cannot make it right now

The crew decide in your parent's best interests. In an emergency the Code of Practice says that will almost always mean urgent treatment without delay, unless a valid advance decision refuses that treatment.

From the Mental Capacity Act Code of Practice (paragraphs 4.40 and 6.35) and the NHS page on when to call 999.

The second branch is the one families worry about. It does not mean the crew will override your parent because they are old or because you are frightened. It applies only when your parent cannot make the decision at that moment, for example because an infection has left them confused and they cannot follow what is being said to them.

Who decides

Whether your parent can make this decision

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 starts from the assumption that every adult can make their own decisions, including about doctors and hospitals. Only a problem with this particular decision, at this particular time, changes that.

The NHS summary of the Act sets out its starting points. Assume a person can decide for themselves unless it is shown they cannot. Help them make the decision wherever possible. And do not treat someone as unable to decide just because the decision is unwise. A father who has always hated hospitals and would rather take his chances at home is entitled to that choice, even when it frightens you.

The law looks at how your parent is making the decision rather than whether it seems sensible. Section 3 of the Act names four things a person has to be able to do. Here they are, put to the one sentence you keep hearing.

I am not going to hospital.

  1. Understand the information

    When it is explained simply, can your parent tell you what the doctor is worried about and why they want to see them?

    Worth telling the doctor: Even after a plain explanation, they cannot say what anyone is worried about.

  2. Retain it

    Can they hold on to that long enough to decide? The Act says a short time is enough.

    Worth telling the doctor: A few minutes later they have no memory of the conversation, again and again.

  3. Use or weigh it

    Can they set what might happen if they go against what might happen if they stay at home?

    Worth telling the doctor: They agree it could be serious, but the reason they give for staying has nothing to do with it, such as a fixed belief that the hospital has closed.

  4. Communicate the decision

    Can they tell you their answer in any way at all: speaking, writing, nodding or pointing?

    Worth telling the doctor: They cannot make their choice known by any means.

If something affecting the mind or brain, such as dementia or a sudden confusion, means your parent cannot do any one of the four for this decision, the law treats them as unable to make it. A professional makes that assessment. A choice you disagree with is not on the list. From sections 2 and 3 of the Mental Capacity Act 2005.

You are not the one who carries out the assessment. The Code of Practice says a doctor or health professional who proposes treatment must assess the person's capacity to consent to it. What you can do is tell that professional what you have seen, especially anything that has changed recently. The Code lists confusion, drowsiness and delirium caused by a physical illness among the things that can take away capacity for a while, so a parent who refuses today may be able to decide again once an infection has been treated.

A lasting power of attorney for health and welfare does not let you overrule your parent while they can still decide. According to gov.uk, it can only be used when they lack the capacity to make the decision themselves. The same law governs bigger decisions too: whether someone can be made to move into a care home turns on exactly the same test.

Without the trip

Bringing the doctor to your parent instead

A refusal to go is not always a refusal to be seen. Several parts of the NHS can see your parent at home, and some of them do not need your parent to leave their chair.

  1. Without leaving their chair

    A phone or video appointment with the GP

    Age UK says a GP may be able to give advice by phone or video as an alternative to going in. Age UK

    What to ask: Ring the surgery and ask for a phone call back from a GP.

  2. The doctor comes to the door

    A GP home visit

    If your parent cannot get to the surgery for medical reasons, they can ask for a home visit. The GP decides whether one is needed. Age UK

    What to ask: Say plainly that your parent is too unwell to travel and describe what you can see.

  3. A team comes within 2 hours

    Urgent community response

    NHS teams that give older people urgent care at home, with access to health and social care professionals within 2 hours, from at least 8am to 8pm, seven days a week. NHS England

    What to ask: Ask the GP or NHS 111 whether the local team can see your parent at home.

  4. Hospital care in their own bed

    A virtual ward, also called hospital at home

    Care that would otherwise need a hospital stay, given safely in their own home, as NHS England describes it. NHS England

    What to ask: Ask the doctor treating your parent whether a virtual ward is an option for them.

  5. Out and back the same day

    A surgery or outpatient appointment

    Some tests and scans need equipment that only the surgery or hospital has. If the journey is what your parent objects to, that part can be planned around them.

    What to ask: Ask for a time of day that suits them, and say if they will need help getting there.

The bar under each heading shows how far your parent would have to go, from their own chair to a trip out and back.

You can ring your parent's GP surgery yourself to say what you have noticed. Guidance from the General Medical Council tells doctors that they should not refuse to listen to the concerns of someone close to a patient on the grounds of confidentiality. The doctor may not be able to tell you anything back without your parent's agreement, and they may tell your parent that you called, so it is kinder to tell your parent first if you can.

If a hospital doctor suggests admission, it is reasonable to ask whether a virtual ward could be used instead. Hospital at home and virtual wards explains how they work and who is involved.

Behind the no

What your parent may be saying no to

When a parent refuses a hospital appointment, the objection is sometimes to the day itself rather than to the doctor. Ask which part worries them most, and listen for it in what they say.

Their front door
  1. Getting there

    “I can't manage the journey.”

    What can change it: Someone goes with them from door to door. If their health means they cannot travel by car or public transport, ask the hospital whether they qualify for NHS non-emergency patient transport.

  2. The wait

    “I'll be sat there all day.”

    What can change it: Ask the clinic for a morning appointment, or whether the appointment can be by phone. Someone sits with them, with their glasses, a drink and anything they need to take at that time.

  3. Being kept in

    “Once they get me in there, I won't come out.”

    What can change it: While your parent can make the decision, agreeing to stay in is their choice too. Say so plainly, and talk before the day about what they would want if a doctor suggests a stay.

  4. Coming home

    “Who's going to help me when I get back?”

    What can change it: Someone comes home with them, makes something to eat and stays until they are settled. Ask the clinic to write down any new instructions so whoever is with them can read them too.

  5. Who is left at home

    “Who will see to the dog?”

    What can change it: Name the person who will feed it, walk it or let it out, and give them a key before the day, so the answer is settled before anyone asks.

Back home again

The fear of being kept in deserves a plain answer rather than reassurance you cannot promise. You cannot know what a doctor will find, and saying "they will send you straight home" can backfire if they do not. What you can say is true: while your parent is able to make the decision, agreeing to stay in hospital and agreeing to treatment are theirs to decide. The NHS page on consent says a refusal from someone with capacity must be respected, with narrow exceptions under the Mental Health Act for treating some mental health conditions.

On the day

A carer to go with your parent and bring them home

If the journey, the wait or the empty house afterwards is what stands in the way, a few hours with someone beside them can change the answer.

A carer can come to your parent's house, help them get ready, travel with them, sit with them while they wait, and come home with them. Once they are back, the carer can make a drink and lunch and stay until your parent is settled. Your parent decides whether the carer comes into the appointment room.

A carer is company and practical help on the day, not a medical escort. A carer does not give clinical advice, cannot agree to treatment on your parent's behalf, and does not take the place of anything the doctor or clinic tells them. On PrimeCarers, carers are self-employed and we do not check qualifications or clinical training. Experience is the carer's own account on their profile, for you to ask about when you speak to them.

An example morning, 4 hours

  1. 9:30The carer arrivesHelps your parent get ready, checks the letter and packs what they need.
  2. 10:15They set off togetherThe carer travels with them, however you have agreed they will get there.
  3. 11:00The appointment and the waitThe carer sits with them, and comes into the room only if your parent wants them to.
  4. 12:30Home againInto the house, a drink, lunch made, any new instructions put somewhere obvious.
  5. 13:30The carer leavesOnce your parent is settled. You could have a message from the carer saying how it went, if your parent is happy for them to tell you.

4 hours at £18 to £25 an hour, with our fee included

£72 to £100

The times are an example. You agree the hours with the carer, and any mileage or travel time only if you both agree it in writing beforehand.

You choose the carer, meet them first, and agree the hours directly with them, and if it goes well you can book the same person next time. Every carer on PrimeCarers has had their identity and right to work checked, holds an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and has had an online interview. Carers are insured while they work.

One thing to settle before the day: under the client contract, a visit you cancel is payable in full unless the reason is unplanned hospitalisation, illness, or a reason you and the carer agree. If there is a chance your parent will say no on the morning, talk to the carer about it when you book. When you are ready, you can search for carers near your parent.

Keeping the door open

If the answer is still no

Sometimes you take every worry away and your parent still refuses. If they can make the decision, that is where things stand for now, and the job becomes keeping them safe and keeping the conversation open.

Tell your parent you will respect their decision and that you will ask again if things change. Agree with them, and with anyone who visits, what would make you ring 111 or 999 regardless, so nobody is deciding that in a panic. Let the GP know what is happening, even if your parent will not see them yet.

A parent who refuses every kind of help, says there is no point, or has stopped caring what happens to them may be low or depressed rather than stubborn. That can be treated, and it is worth raising with the GP. Mental health in later life explains the signs and where help comes from.

Questions

Questions families ask

No. If your parent can understand, retain and weigh up the decision and tell you their answer, the choice is theirs, even if it seems unwise. You can ring 999 in an emergency, and the crew will then judge whether your parent is able to refuse. Only when a person lacks capacity can the professionals act in their best interests.

You can ring the surgery and tell them what you have seen, and you can ask whether a phone call, a video appointment or a home visit is possible. Your mother still has to agree to be seen or examined. Asking her which kind of appointment she would accept gives her a say, which is easier to agree to than an appointment made without her.

Yes. General Medical Council guidance tells doctors not to refuse to listen to the concerns of someone close to a patient on the grounds of confidentiality. The GP may not be able to share anything with you without your parent's consent, and may tell your parent you called.

The same law applies: if they can make the decision, they can say no. Tell the physiotherapist which part they object to, whether that is the pain, the time it takes or getting to a clinic, and ask whether the exercises can be changed, made shorter or done at home. Family or a carer can keep them company and remind them of the times the physiotherapist set, but changing the exercises is the physiotherapist's decision.

Not while your parent can make the decision themselves. A health and welfare lasting power of attorney can only be used when the person lacks capacity to make that decision, and the attorney then has to act in their best interests. How mental capacity is assessed explains what that involves.

Would company on the day change their mind?

Search for carers near your parent, look at their profiles, rates and reviews, and talk to the ones you like about going with your parent to an appointment and staying until they are home.

Free to searchNo obligationID and DBS checkedYou choose the carer