PrimeCarers

Home careDeciding

The pros and cons of home care, and whether it is safe

Home care keeps your parent in their own house with one-to-one help from a carer the family has chosen, and the value of the house stays out of the council's means test. Against that, nobody is there between visits or at night unless that is paid for, and a carer is not a nurse. Whether it can work for your parent depends on what happens in the hours between visits, and on whether the help they need fits into visits at all.

See who could help your parent at home

Enter the town or postcode where your parent lives. You can read the profiles of carers nearby, see their rates and reviews, and message the ones you like before the family sits down to decide.

Free to search. Compare profiles, rates and reviews, then discuss the help you need with the carer.

By , founder of PrimeCarers  ·  Updated  ·  9 min read · See a day with visits

Part of our guide to home care.

A day with visits

What a day of home care looks like, visits and gaps together

Many of the pros and cons of home care come from one fact: help arrives in visits. Seeing a whole day laid out makes the trade-off easier to talk about as a family.

One day at home with three one-hour visits

3 hours with a carer, 21 hours without

A carer is there Your parent is on their own
  1. 00:00to 08:00The night8 hours on their ownA pendant alarm, a clear path to the toilet, a light by the bed
  2. 08:00to 09:00Morningcarer visitUp, washed, dressed, breakfast, tablets prompted
  3. 09:00to 12:30Late morning3.5 hours on their ownA drink and the phone within reach, a call from family
  4. 12:30to 13:30Lunchcarer visitA hot meal, a drink, a check on how the morning went
  5. 13:30to 18:00Afternoon4.5 hours on their ownThe longest stretch alone, and a good time for a call or a companion visit
  6. 18:00to 19:00Eveningcarer visitTea, a wash, ready for bed, the house locked
  7. 19:00to midnightLate evening5 hours on their ownAlarm worn, key safe for anyone who has to come in

This day, seven days a week

£378 to £525

21 hours of visits at £18 to £25 an hour on PrimeCarers, our fee included. Food and household bills are on top.

A residential care home week

£1,300

The median in England among homes that publish a fee. It includes the room, meals, bills and staff at night.

During each visit your parent has a carer's full attention, in their own kitchen and bathroom, at the times that suit their routine. That is the strength of care at home, and no care home can match it hour for hour. The weakness is the time in between. With three visits, your parent spends 21 hours of the day on their own, including the whole night.

For a parent who can get to the toilet, make a drink and use an alarm, those gaps are manageable, and the week costs a good deal less than a care home place. For a parent who falls at night, cannot remember to eat, or needs help several times between visits, the gaps are the problem, and more visits, a night carer or a live-in carer are what would have to fill them. Visits can be booked for as many hours as are needed, and home care explains the different ways of arranging it.

What home care gives

What staying at home gives your parent

What care at home keeps for your parent, and what each part depends on.

One person's attention, and the same person each time. For the hour a carer is there, your parent is the only person they are looking after. On PrimeCarers you choose the carer from their profile, meet them first, agree the hours and routine with them directly, and can keep the same person, so your parent gets to know one face rather than a rota.

The house, the routine and the people in it. Your parent keeps their own bed, their own chair and the order their morning happens in. A couple stays in the same house, and a dog or cat stays where it lives. For someone who is confused, not having to learn a new building and a new set of faces matters a great deal.

Paying for the hours needed, not the whole week. Hourly visits on PrimeCarers are £18 to £25 an hour with our fee included. Three one-hour visits a day is 21 hours a week, £378 to £525, against a median of £1,300 a week for a residential care home place in England among homes that publish a fee. The care home fee includes food, bills and staff at night, so the comparison narrows as the hours go up, and home care is not always the cheaper route. Care home per week versus home care per week lays the two out like for like. For a couple, one live-in carer looking after both is about £1,350 a week, against £2,600 for two care home places.

The house stays out of the means test. The NHS puts it plainly: if a paid carer comes into your home, "the value of your house will not be included in the financial assessment". For a permanent move into a care home it is included, unless a partner, a close relative who is 60 or over or disabled, or a child under 16 still lives there. Savings are counted on both routes, and the council generally helps with the cost only below £23,250.

The drawbacks

The drawbacks of home care, and what can be done about each

Each drawback below has something that can be done about it at home. Each also has a point where the house stops being able to answer it, and that point is what to look for in your parent.

  1. Nobody is there between visits

    What helps at home

    A pendant alarm worn all day, a key safe so a responder can get in, a phone and a drink within reach, and a family call at a set time. Visits can be added or lengthened.

    When it points to a care home

    Your parent cannot press an alarm or does not remember to wear it, or is falling in the gaps despite all of the above.

  2. Nights are not covered by daytime visits

    What helps at home

    A carer sleeping in the house from £160 a night, a carer awake all night from £165, or a live-in carer at about £1,120 a week, all with our fee included.

    When it points to a care home

    Help is needed several times every night, or needs two people, and paying for that at home has become more than a care home place.

  3. A carer is not a nurse

    What helps at home

    District nurses visit for wounds, catheters and injections, arranged through the GP. A carer can prompt prescribed medicines and notice a change, but does not take on clinical tasks unless a nurse has trained them and delegated it.

    When it points to a care home

    Nursing is needed around the clock rather than in visits. That is what a nursing home has and a house does not.

  4. Home can be lonely

    What helps at home

    Longer visits with time to talk, a companion visit in the afternoon, a day centre or lunch club, and the neighbours and friends who already call.

    When it points to a care home

    What your parent misses is other people every day, and they would rather live among them than wait for visitors.

  5. A lot rests on one carer

    What helps at home

    Agree from the start who covers holidays and illness: a second carer who has met your parent, or family on a set day. Keep a short written routine so anyone can pick it up.

    When it points to a care home

    There is no family nearby to step in, and gaps in cover would leave your parent without help.

  6. The house may need changing

    What helps at home

    An occupational therapist can assess the house through the council. Grab rails, a bed downstairs, a stairlift or a level shower can follow, and the council may help with the cost.

    When it points to a care home

    The only bathroom is upstairs, the stairs are no longer safe, and the changes cannot be made in time or at all.

If the things under what helps at home would cover each drawback for your parent, care at home can work with those things in place. If two or three of the descriptions under when it points to a care home fit, a care home deserves a serious look, and that is a sign of how much help they need rather than a failure of anyone's effort. Live-in care answers the first two drawbacks but brings its own, which are set out in the disadvantages of live-in care.

Is it safe?

Is home care safe? What makes it safe, and who to tell if it is not

Home care is as safe as the arrangements around it. Neither home care nor a care home is safer in every case, so it helps to look at the layers that make care at home safe and see which ones your parent already has.

A plan that someone has written down

A council care needs assessment, free whatever your parent's savings, sets out what help is needed and when. Review how it is going after the first few weeks and again whenever something changes.

A house set up against falls

The NHS advice is to clear clutter and anything that can be tripped on, such as loose wires or rugs, use a non-slip mat in the bath or shower, fit grab rails in the bathroom and rails on steps, and keep up activities that improve strength and balance.

A way to call for help, and a way in

A personal alarm worn as a pendant or on the wrist, or a mobile phone carried at all times. A key safe by the door lets a responder, a carer or a paramedic in without breaking a door down. The council may provide telecare after an assessment.

A carer you have checked and chosen

Carers on PrimeCarers have their identity and right to work checked, an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and an online interview. We do not check training, qualifications or references, so ask about those yourself, look at the DBS certificate and its date, and meet the carer before the first visit.

Your parent, at home

Each layer sits inside the one before it. If one is missing, the layers inside it have to carry more.

The plan is the layer to start with. In a care needs assessment, a social worker or occupational therapist from the council looks at what your parent can and cannot do, and at the risks in the house and the day. Councils may provide telecare, such as a personal alarm, after an assessment, and may charge for it.

When you meet a carer, ask about the part of the day you are worried about and what they have done before. Experience is the carer's own account on their profile, so it is yours to check at interview.

If you think your parent is being harmed or neglected, by anyone, ring the council's adult social care team and say it is a safeguarding concern. Under section 42 of the Care Act 2014, when a council has reasonable cause to suspect that an adult with care needs is at risk of abuse or neglect and cannot protect themselves, it must make whatever enquiries it thinks necessary. If someone is in immediate danger, ring 999.

Nursing and nights

When nursing or the night is the deciding question

Nursing care and help through the night are the two needs that daytime visits cover least well. Each can be met at home up to a point.

Nursing. The pros of a nursing home are that one or more qualified nurses are on duty at all times, and the building is set up for it. The cons are the same as any care home: a move, a rota rather than one familiar person, and a median fee of £1,595 a week among homes in England that publish one. At home, nursing comes from district nurses who visit for wounds, catheters and injections, arranged through the GP. Carers on PrimeCarers are not nurses, and we do not check training, qualifications or nursing registration. A carer can prompt prescribed medicines and write down what was taken, and they notice when something changes, but they do not give injections or change dressings unless a nurse has trained that carer and delegated the task in writing. The rest of what a care home has and a house does not is set out in what a care home offers that home care cannot.

Nights. A care home has staff in the building all night. At home, a carer sleeping in the house is from £160 a night with our fee included, a carer awake all night from £165, and a live-in carer about £1,120 a week. Seven paid nights on top of daytime visits can cost more than a care home week, so if nights are the problem, price them before anything else.

Trying it first

How to try home care before the family decides

You do not have to settle the question in one meeting. Care at home can be tried for a few weeks, and what happens in those weeks will tell you more than any list of pros and cons.

Start with the visits you are sure of, such as the morning, and the safety layers above. Keep a short note each day of how the gaps went: whether your parent ate, whether the alarm was worn, whether there were any falls or near misses. After the first few weeks, look at the notes together and decide whether to add visits, add nights, or look at care homes. The NICE quality standard for home care suggests reviewing how home care is going within the first six weeks.

A trial is low commitment. Under the client contract, hourly care can be ended with 48 hours' notice, and PrimeCarers charges nothing itself to cancel. When the family is ready, you can look at carers near your parent and compare their rates.

Questions

Questions families ask about home care

For a few hours a day, yes. Three one-hour visits a day on PrimeCarers come to £378 to £525 a week with our fee included, against a median of £1,300 for a residential care home place among homes that publish a fee. Once nights or many hours a day are needed, home care can cost the same or more, and the house still has its own bills.

A nursing home has qualified nurses on duty day and night, staff in the building, and other people around at mealtimes. Against that, it means moving, the staff change with the rota, the fee is higher than a residential home, and the value of the house can count in the means test. Nursing home vs care home explains how the two differ.

It can be, when the right things are in place: an assessment of the risks, a house set up against falls, an alarm your parent wears, and carers you have checked and met. Clinical tasks at home are done by district nurses or other health professionals, not by a carer unless a nurse has trained them and delegated the task.

Yes, in visits. District nurses come to the house for wounds, catheters and injections, arranged through the GP, and a private nurse can be paid for when more is needed. Carers on PrimeCarers are not nurses, and we do not check nursing registration. A private nurse at home explains how that is arranged and what it involves.

Hospice care can be given at home as well as in a hospice, so someone can stay in familiar surroundings with family close. At home, the hours between the hospice team's visits fall to the family or to paid help, which is the main thing to plan for. Hospice care explained covers how it works and how to ask for it.

Yes. Ask to see the certificate and check the name and the date it was issued. On PrimeCarers, every carer has an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, with identity and right to work checked. Do private carers need a DBS? explains what the check shows.

Want to see whether home care could work?

Search carers near your parent, read their profiles and rates, and message the ones you like. Free, and no obligation.

Free to searchNo obligationID and DBS checkedYou choose the carer