PrimeCarers

Private carersChecks, law and money

What is an introductory care agency?

An introductory care agency is a company, or an online platform, that finds self-employed carers and introduces them to you, then has no ongoing role in directing or controlling the care. A managed care agency employs its care workers, plans and supervises the care itself and, in England, must be registered with the Care Quality Commission; an introductory agency does not have to be.

See what carers near you charge

Enter the town or postcode where care is needed. You can compare carers, their rates and their reviews before deciding which model suits you.

Free to search. Compare profiles, rates and reviews, then discuss the help you need with the carer.

By , founder of PrimeCarers  ·  Updated  ·  14 min read · See the three models side by side

A middle-aged couple comparing four printed leaflets side by side, a laptop and mugs of tea, at a kitchen table

Part of our guide to private carers.

What it is

What an introductory care agency is, and what it is not

The name describes the one thing the company does: it introduces. Everything that follows the introduction belongs to you and the carer.

An introductory care agency recruits carers who work for themselves, checks them to whatever standard it has chosen, and matches them to families who need care at home. You choose the carer, agree the hours and the tasks with them, and tell them how you want things done. The agency's part is the finding, the vetting and usually the paperwork and payments. It does not write or change the care plan, supervise the carer, set the rota or decide who covers when the carer is away. You will also see it called an introduction agency, an introduction service or, online, a care platform or marketplace.

A managed agency works the other way round. It is the care provider: it employs or engages the care workers, assesses your relative, writes the care plan, sends staff from its own rota, supervises and trains them, and answers for the care they give. In England that makes it a provider of a regulated activity, which has to be registered with the Care Quality Commission (CQC). You will see it called a domiciliary care agency, a home care agency, a regulated agency or a fully managed service.

The words companies use for themselves

Regulated activity
The legal term for work the CQC has to register. Personal care in the place somebody lives is one, which is why a home care agency must register and a companionship service need not.
Introductory agency
A company that introduces a self-employed carer to you and has no ongoing part in directing the care. Also called an introduction service.
Managed agency
A company that employs care workers, plans the care and sends staff from its own rota. Also called a domiciliary or home care agency.
Franchise
A local company trading under a national brand, with its own owner, staff and CQC registration. The brand is shared and the legal responsibility is not.
Platform
An online introductory service. Carers list themselves, families search and choose, and the checks, contract and payments run through it.
Personal assistant
A carer employed directly by the person they care for, frequently paid for with a council direct payment. The work is the same, and the name describes the employment relationship.

A franchise is a managed agency under a shared national name, so everything this page says about managed agencies applies to it, branch by branch. A platform is an introductory agency that works online. The label a company uses does not settle which kind it is. What settles it is who directs and controls the care, which is the test the law uses.

Side by side

Introductory agency, managed agency or employing a carer yourself

The same questions asked of all three ways to arrange care at home. Nothing in the table makes one model correct; they divide the work and the risk differently.

Three ways to arrange care at home, compared

Who chooses the carer

Introductory agency or platform
You do, from a shortlist or from profiles.
Managed (regulated) agency
The agency. You can state preferences, and the rota decides.
Employing a carer directly
You do, and you do the advertising and interviewing.

Who directs the care

Introductory agency or platform
You and the carer. The introducer has no ongoing role.
Managed (regulated) agency
The agency, through its care plan, supervisors and registered manager.
Employing a carer directly
You do.

Who is regulated

Introductory agency or platform
Nobody, in England. The introducer is outside CQC registration and so is the carer.
Managed (regulated) agency
The agency. In England the CQC registers, inspects and rates it.
Employing a carer directly
Nobody. A carer working wholly under your direction is outside CQC registration.

Who employs and pays the carer

Introductory agency or platform
Nobody employs them: the carer is self-employed and contracts with you. You pay the carer, often through the introducer.
Managed (regulated) agency
The agency employs and pays its care workers. You pay the agency.
Employing a carer directly
You are the employer, with payroll, tax and insurance duties.

Checks on the carer

Introductory agency or platform
Whatever the introducer chooses to do. The CQC rules on staff checks do not apply to it, so ask for the list in writing.
Managed (regulated) agency
Set by regulation: identity, criminal record certificate, conduct in previous care work, qualifications, full employment history.
Employing a carer directly
Whatever you do yourself.

Cover when the carer is ill

Introductory agency or platform
No rota. You can ask the introducer for another introduction, and the decision stays with you.
Managed (regulated) agency
The agency arranges cover from its own staff.
Employing a carer directly
None unless you arranged it in advance.

Typical cost structure

Introductory agency or platform
The carer's own rate, plus the introducer's charge: a one-off or weekly fee, or a commission inside the rate.
Managed (regulated) agency
One hourly or weekly rate to the agency, typically £28 to £35 an hour, covering wages, office, training and cover.
Employing a carer directly
The wage, around £16 to £18 an hour, plus employer costs on top.

If something goes wrong

Introductory agency or platform
You raise it with the carer. No statutory complaints system. Council safeguarding and the police still apply.
Managed (regulated) agency
A complaints system the law requires, then the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman. The CQC takes concerns.
Employing a carer directly
Between you and your employee. Council safeguarding and the police still apply.

What you are responsible for

Introductory agency or platform
Choosing well, directing the care, planning cover, and checking the carer really is self-employed.
Managed (regulated) agency
Paying the bill and telling the agency what you want.
Employing a carer directly
Everything: checks, contract, payroll, holiday and sick pay, pension, insurance, cover.

Regulatory position is for England; see below for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Agency and direct-hire prices are market figures quoted for comparison, not our prices. Checked 11 November 2026.

If the question you are really asking is whether to use an agency at all, agency or private carer makes our own case for one side of it, and private carers compared with agency carers covers the day-to-day difference. This page stays with the definitions.

What the law says

The exemption from CQC registration, and where it stops

This is the position in England. Introductory agencies are not overlooked by the regulations; they are written out of them, on one condition.

In England it is a criminal offence to carry on a regulated activity without being registered with the CQC (Health and Social Care Act 2008, section 10). Personal care is one of those activities when it is provided to people who cannot provide it for themselves because of old age, illness or disability, in the place where they live (Regulated Activities Regulations 2014, Schedule 1, paragraph 1).

Personal care has a precise meaning. Regulation 2 defines it as physical assistance with eating or drinking, toileting, washing or bathing, dressing, oral care, or the care of skin, hair and nails, and also prompting together with supervision of those tasks where the person cannot decide to do them without it. A service that only offers company, shopping or housework is not providing personal care and does not need to register, whoever runs it.

Paragraph 1(3) of the same Schedule then lists what the regulated activity does not cover. Sub-paragraph (b) is the introductory agency exemption. It excludes:

the introduction of carers to an individual (other than a service provider) by a person (including an employment agency or an employment business) having no ongoing role in the direction or control of the service provided to that individual

Sub-paragraph (c) excludes a carer employed by an individual, or by a related third party such as an attorney, without an agency or employment business involved, who works wholly under that person's direction and control. That is why a carer you take on yourself does not register either.

The CQC's own guidance says the same thing in fewer words: "introductory agencies do not need to register with CQC as they do not have any ongoing role in the personal care that care workers provide to people after they are introduced" (CQC, Personal care: ongoing role, introductory agencies and individual care workers, page last updated 26 May 2022). Its scope of registration guidance on personal care lists the same exception.

So the exemption depends on what a company does after the introduction, not on what it calls itself. The CQC guidance gives examples on both sides of the line, summarised here.

Not an ongoing role, says the CQC

  • Checking and vetting carers before accepting them onto its books
  • Helping you clarify what care and support you need, so the right carer can be introduced
  • Pointing carers to general training that is not specific to one client
  • Charging a one-off fee for an introduction
  • Asking whether you are satisfied with the introduction service itself
  • Introducing an additional or replacement carer when you ask for one
  • A purely payroll function, charged separately

May be an ongoing role, needing registration

  • Monitoring the care the carer gives, or using feedback to direct how it is done
  • Arranging rotas of care workers on your behalf
  • Managing the replacement of a carer without you making the decision
  • Continuing to charge for the carer's service after a one-off introduction fee
  • Reviewing and updating care needs when you have not asked
  • Making changes to an active care plan
  • Requiring carers to attend its supervision, wear its uniform or use its paperwork

The right-hand list is the CQC's list of things that "may constitute" an ongoing role. It is guidance about how the CQC reads the test, and the legal test itself remains direction or control. Ask any introducer how it is paid, and what it does and does not do once the carer has started. How PrimeCarers charges is set out on our pricing page.

Registration is worth something, and it is fair to say what. A registered provider must make sure the people it employs are of good character and have the qualifications, competence, skills and experience the work needs (regulation 19). It must hold, for each one, proof of identity, a criminal record certificate where the role requires it, evidence of conduct in previous care work, evidence of relevant qualifications and a full employment history (Schedule 3). It must run an accessible complaints system and act on what it finds (regulation 16). None of those duties applies to an introductory agency. How home care is regulated explains how to read a CQC rating, and whether self-employed carers need CQC registration covers the carer's side.

Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland

The position outside England

The CQC regulates only in England. Each of the other three nations has its own regulator and its own legislation, and they do not all treat introducers the same way.

England

Regulator
Care Quality Commission (CQC)
Introductory agencies
Excluded from registration where the introducer has no ongoing role in the direction or control of the care.

Wales

Regulator
Care Inspectorate Wales (CIW)
Introductory agencies
A near-identical exclusion is written into the Welsh Act: an introducer with no ongoing role in the direction or control of the care and support is not treated as providing a domiciliary support service.

Scotland

Regulator
Care Inspectorate
Introductory agencies
The Scottish Act has no equivalent wording for introducers. It excepts an individual who personally and solely gives the care. Check with the Care Inspectorate.

Northern Ireland

Regulator
Regulation and Quality Improvement Authority (RQIA)
Introductory agencies
Drawn wider. A domiciliary care agency includes an undertaking that arranges care, and the agency regulations count introducing a care worker to a person for employment by them. Check with the RQIA.

Read from the legislation on 11 November 2026. This is a summary, not legal advice; the regulator decides whether a particular service must register.

Wales. Paragraph 8(3) of Schedule 1 to the Regulation and Inspection of Social Care (Wales) Act 2016 says that a person who introduces individuals who provide a domiciliary support service to individuals who may wish to receive it, "but has no ongoing role in the direction or control of the care and support provided", is not to be treated as providing that service, whether or not the introduction is for profit. Care Inspectorate Wales registers and inspects the services that are covered.

Scotland. Care at home falls under the definition of a "support service" in schedule 12 to the Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010. That definition does not apply where the provider is "an individual who personally and solely gives the care or support in question", which is how a self-employed carer working alone sits outside it. We could not find wording in the Act that deals with introducers by name, and services can also be excepted by regulations, so we are not going to state a position. If you are using or running an introductory service in Scotland, check with the Care Inspectorate.

Northern Ireland. Article 2 of the Health and Personal Social Services (Quality, Improvement and Regulation) (Northern Ireland) Order 2003 defines a domiciliary care agency as an undertaking "which consists of or includes arranging the provision of prescribed services" in people's own homes. Regulation 2 of the Domiciliary Care Agencies Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2007 then says that supplying a domiciliary care worker includes "the introduction of a domiciliary care worker by an agency to a service user for employment by him". That is a wider net than the English one, and there is no exclusion in those provisions matching England's. Check with the RQIA how it applies to any service you are considering.

Employer, tax, insurance, DBS

Who employs the carer, and what follows from it

The three models put the employer in three different places, and tax, insurance and criminal record checks all follow from where it sits.

Managed agency: the agency is the employer

The CQC describes regulated agencies as normally employing their care workers directly, or hiring them from an employment agency. Wages, tax, holiday pay, sick pay and employers' liability insurance are the agency's to deal with, and so is requesting the criminal record check.

Introductory agency: nobody is, if the carer is truly self-employed

The carer runs their own business, pays their own tax and National Insurance, and has no holiday or sick pay from you. That holds only if the working arrangement is self-employment in fact and not just on paper.

Hiring directly: you may well be the employer

If you take a carer on yourself and they are not self-employed, you are their employer, with everything that brings.

When a family becomes an employer. GOV.UK's guidance on employing someone to work in your home says you are usually the employer of anyone who works in your home if you hire them and "they're not self-employed or paid through an agency". It adds, of carers specifically: "You're classed as an employer if you pay a carer or personal assistant directly, even if you get money from your local council ('direct payments') or the NHS to pay for them." An employer must check the person's right to work, have employers' liability insurance, register as an employer, run payroll, and deduct Income Tax and National Insurance. The same page says: "You cannot ask your employee to become self-employed."

How self-employment is tested. Status depends on how the work is actually done, not on the word in the contract. GOV.UK's employment status guidance says a person is self-employed if they run their business for themselves and take responsibility for its success or failure, and lists the signs: they quote for work, are not under direct supervision, submit invoices, pay their own tax and National Insurance, and get no holiday or sick pay. HMRC's Check Employment Status for Tax tool (CEST) gives HMRC's view of a specific engagement, and HMRC says it will stand by the result as long as the information given is accurate. If you are unsure about a carer, run it. This matters most with one carer working long, fixed hours for one family and nobody else, which is where the line is thinnest. Self-employed carer or employee goes through the tests.

Insurance. An employer must hold employers' liability insurance of at least £5 million from an authorised insurer from the day they become one, and can be fined £2,500 for every day without it. A managed agency carries that for its staff. A family that employs a carer directly must buy it. A self-employed carer is not your employee, so the question becomes whether the carer holds public liability insurance of their own or is covered by a policy the introducer arranges. Ask which, and ask what it excludes. Private carer insurance explains the types.

DBS checks. A managed agency requests criminal record checks on its own staff, as their employer. A private individual cannot: the Disclosure and Barring Service's guidance for private individuals employing self-employed workers or personal employees says "you cannot apply for a DBS check on behalf of the person you are looking to recruit". Since 21 January 2026 an eligible self-employed person or personal employee can obtain an Enhanced DBS check, with barred lists where the role qualifies, on themselves through an umbrella body (DBS guidance). You can then ask to see the original certificate, and check it free on the DBS Update Service if the carer subscribes. That guidance covers England and Wales. Scotland uses the PVG scheme and Northern Ireland uses AccessNI. An introductory agency may obtain or inspect these certificates as part of its vetting; ask which checks it does and how recent they must be. Background checks for private carers sets out what each check confirms.

What each costs

How the three models are priced

A managed agency quotes one rate that pays for a company as well as a carer. An introductory agency splits the price into the carer's rate and its own charge, and the way that charge is taken varies.

An hour of care at home, by modelWhat a family pays per hour
  1. Employing a carer directlyBefore employer costs£16–£18Payroll, holiday pay, pension contributions and insurance sit on top of this figure, not inside it.
  2. A carer on PrimeCarersOne introductory platform, our charge included£18–£25The dot is the typical rate, £19.47. Nothing is added at checkout.
  3. A managed agencyFranchised branches price the same way£28–£35The rate pays the care worker, the office, training, supervision, insurance and the cover rota.
  4. Other introductory agenciesCharging structures varyAskNo figure is given, because the charge can be a one-off sum, a weekly amount or a share of the rate, and we have no reliable range to quote.

PrimeCarers rates include our charge. Agency and direct-hire figures are market figures quoted for comparison and are not our prices.

Introductory agencies charge in three broad ways: a one-off sum for the introduction, a weekly or daily amount for as long as the carer works, or a share of the carer's rate on every booking. Ask which applies, whether it is inside or on top of the rate you were quoted, and what you owe if the arrangement ends early or you later engage the carer privately.

On PrimeCarers the carer sets the rate and our share is already inside the figure on their profile: £18 to £25 an hour, typically £19.47, and live-in care from £1,050 a week. The carer keeps about £15.58 of a £19.47 hour. Our pricing gives the exact shares for visits, long shifts and live-in care. A managed agency charges £28 to £35 an hour, and live-in care typically about £1,610 a week; roughly £12 of a £28 agency hour reaches the care worker. The difference buys an employer, a rota, supervision, training and a company that answers for the care. Whether that is worth paying for depends on how much of the arranging your family can take on.

VAT. Welfare services supplied by a state-regulated provider, which includes a CQC-registered domiciliary care agency, are exempt from VAT (HMRC VAT Notice 701/2, section 3.3). The same notice says, at paragraph 5.1.1, that an agent's "commission, fee or any other charge" for arranging and administering the supply is standard-rated. So an introducer that is registered for VAT has VAT in its own charge, and you should ask whether a quoted price includes it. On PrimeCarers it does: the VAT on our share is paid out of that share, and nothing is added to the carer's rate.

Some introducers, ours included, sell an optional layer of help on top. On PrimeCarers the managed service adds 5% to the rate, or 10% for live-in care under Fully Managed: our team finds and proposes carers and can place bookings on your instruction. You still choose the carers and decide the care, so it does not turn us into a managed agency in the regulatory sense, and the names are easy to confuse.

The downsides

What the introductory model leaves with you

We run an introductory platform, so this is the section where we have most reason to go easy. These are the real costs of the model, and they apply to us.

Nobody inspects the service

There is no regulator, no inspection report and no rating to look up, for the introducer or for the carer. The quality of the vetting is whatever the company says it is, so ask for it in writing.

You direct the care

There is no registered manager, no supervisor and no care plan written and reviewed by the company. If your relative's needs change, noticing and acting on it falls to the family and the carer.

Cover is not guaranteed

When the carer is ill or on holiday, no rota stands behind them. An introducer can offer another introduction, which takes time and is an effort, not an obligation to send somebody.

No statutory complaints route about the care

A registered provider must run a complaints system by law. With a self-employed carer you have the contract between you, and the council safeguarding team and the police if somebody is at risk.

The employment status risk is yours to watch

If the arrangement is really employment, the tax and employment duties can land on the family. A sound contract and a carer who genuinely runs their own business reduce the risk; they do not remove the need to check.

Some protections do not depend on the model. A council must make enquiries where it has reasonable cause to suspect that an adult with care and support needs is experiencing, or at risk of, abuse or neglect and cannot protect themselves (Care Act 2014, section 42), whoever is providing the care. Theft and assault are police matters on every route. The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman says it looks at all adult social care complaints, including privately funded care; its role is clearest with a registered provider, so ask it directly before relying on it for a dispute with a self-employed carer or an introducer.

On cover in particular: under the contract PrimeCarers provides, a carer may put a substitute forward and you can object for a good reason. Unless the substitute is also a carer on PrimeCarers they have not been through our checks and are not covered by the insurance we arrange. Our support team will try to help you find another carer at short notice, and with no rota behind it that is an effort, not a guarantee. The dependable answer on any introductory route is a second carer who already knows your relative. When your carer is ill or on holiday explains how to set that up.

Who it suits, what to ask

Who each model suits, and what to ask an introductory agency

The choice turns less on price than on two things: whether a missed visit would be unsafe, and how much of the organising the family can do.

An introductory agency or platform suits you if

you want to choose the carer and keep the same person, somebody in the family can direct the care and deal with the occasional gap, and the needs are stable enough that nobody has to supervise clinically.

A managed, regulated agency suits you if

a missed visit would be unsafe and nobody could step in, the needs are complex or changing fast, nobody in the family can take on the organising, or you want an inspected provider that is answerable for the care.

Employing a carer directly suits you if

you already know and trust the person, the hours are regular and long-term, and you are willing to be an employer or to pay a payroll service to handle that side.

If you have settled on the introductory route, these are the questions that separate one introducer from another. A good one will answer all of them without discomfort, and that includes us.

Questions to ask an introductory agency

0 of 10 ticked

Status and regulation

Checks on the carer

Money

When things go wrong

If you are comparing named companies, our provider comparisons set several of them side by side, and websites to find a carer covers the platforms. For live-in care specifically, how to choose a live-in care company applies the same questions.

Questions

Questions about introductory care agencies

An introductory care agency is a company or online platform that finds and vets self-employed carers and introduces them to families, then has no ongoing role in directing or controlling the care. The family chooses the carer, contracts with them and directs the work. In England an introductory agency does not have to register with the Care Quality Commission, because the regulations exclude the introduction of carers by somebody with no ongoing role in the direction or control of the service.

A managed agency employs its care workers, writes the care plan, runs the rota, supervises the staff and arranges cover, so it is the care provider and in England must be registered with the CQC. An introductory agency introduces you to a self-employed carer and then steps back, so the arrangement is between you and the carer, you direct the care, and the agency is not registered or inspected. A managed agency usually costs more and carries more of the responsibility.

No. Paragraph 1(3)(b) of Schedule 1 to the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014 excludes the introduction of carers to an individual by a person having no ongoing role in the direction or control of the service provided. The CQC's guidance says introductory agencies do not need to register for that reason. An agency that goes further, for example by arranging rotas, monitoring the care or changing care plans, may need to register.

Yes. In England and Wales the exemption for introducers is written into the legislation itself. What would be unlawful in England is providing personal care as a business, or directing and controlling it, without CQC registration. Northern Ireland defines a domiciliary care agency more widely and Scotland's legislation is worded differently, so check with the RQIA or the Care Inspectorate there.

Yes. PrimeCarers is an introductory platform. We are not a care agency and we are not registered with the CQC. Carers on PrimeCarers are self-employed, families choose their carer and direct the care, and we do not plan, supervise or manage it. We check identity, right to work and an accepted criminal record check, and interview each carer online. We do not check qualifications, training or references. How we vet carers sets out each check.

Nobody, provided the carer is self-employed in fact. The carer runs their own business, pays their own tax and National Insurance and contracts with you directly. If the arrangement is really employment, the family can be treated as the employer, with payroll and insurance duties. HMRC's Check Employment Status for Tax tool gives its view of a specific arrangement. Self-employed carer or employee explains the tests.

Some do, and the CQC rules that set a registered provider's checks do not apply to an introductory agency, so ask which checks it carries out. A managed agency must hold a criminal record certificate for its staff where the role requires one. A private individual cannot apply for a DBS check on somebody else; since 21 January 2026 an eligible self-employed carer can obtain an Enhanced DBS check on themselves through an umbrella body and show you the certificate.

The carer tells you and the next step is yours. An introductory agency can introduce a replacement when you ask, and it has no rota obliged to send somebody. The CQC treats managing replacement cover without the person making the decision as a sign of an ongoing role that needs registration. The practical answer is to have a second carer who already knows your relative. When your carer is ill or on holiday explains how.

Usually, because you are not paying for a management layer. A managed agency typically charges £28 to £35 an hour. Carers on PrimeCarers, one introductory platform, charge £18 to £25 an hour with our charge included. Other introducers price differently, some with a weekly amount on top of the carer's rate, so compare the total. The saving comes with more of the organising and the risk sitting with you.

Neither is better in general. A managed, regulated agency is the safer choice where a missed visit would be unsafe, needs are complex or changing, or nobody in the family can organise the care. An introductory agency suits families who want to choose the carer, keep the same person and pay less, and who can direct the care and plan their own cover.

See what a carer near you charges

Compare profiles, rates and reviews of self-employed carers, then talk to the ones you like. Free to search, and there is no obligation.

Free to searchNo obligationID and DBS checkedYou choose the carer