PrimeCarers

Elderly careTalking with a parent

My elderly mother is very demanding

You set limits without guilt by answering what sits under the demands, not each demand, and by making sure you are not the only company she has. Constant calls, complaining and guilt trips can come from loneliness, fear, pain, a loss of control or low mood, and if the change is new her GP should look first. Then a calm, repeated no, fixed times she can count on, and other people in her week make the limits hold.

Find a regular companion for your mum

If she cannot bear being alone and you are the only person she calls, someone who visits on the same days each week can carry part of that. Search near her home for carers who offer companionship, read their profiles, and meet the ones you like with her.

Free to search. Compare profiles, rates and reviews, then discuss the help you need with the carer.

By , founder of PrimeCarers  ·  Updated  ·  15 min read

Part of our guide to elderly care.

What may be behind it

What may sit behind the demands and the complaining

A demand can be the only way she has found of asking for something she finds harder to name. Seeing what that is changes what you answer.

When a mother who once managed everything starts ringing four times a day, criticising every visit and saying she is a burden, it is easy to hear it as an attack. Read it first as a signal. The NHS says older people are at particular risk of loneliness if they live alone or do not have regular contact with others, and bereavement, illness and the loss of a role all add to it. Fear of falling, of nights alone or of what is happening to her own mind can sound like bossiness. Pain that nobody has treated makes anyone short-tempered.

What she says, and what may sit underneath it

These are possibilities to notice, not a diagnosis. Several can be true at once.

  1. Can you come over? I do not want to be on my own tonight.

    May sit underneath

    Fear of being alone

    Evenings and nights are when an empty house feels biggest. The request is for a person in the room, not for any particular job.

    What tends to help: A fixed evening call she can wait for, and someone in the house on the days you cannot be.

  2. You never come to see me. Nobody cares what happens to me.

    May sit underneath

    Loneliness

    If you are the only person she talks to most days, every visit you miss is the whole of her company gone.

    What tends to help: More people in her week, so the weight does not rest on your visits alone.

  3. Fetch me this. No, not that one. I will do it myself, then.

    May sit underneath

    Loss of control

    When someone can no longer do things for herself, ordering the few things she can still decide is one way of keeping a say in her own life.

    What tends to help: Choices she can make: which day the companion comes, what they do together, what is for lunch.

  4. My back is agony and that doctor is useless.

    May sit underneath

    Pain

    Pain that has never been properly treated wears down anyone’s patience, and an older person may complain about everything except the pain itself.

    What tends to help: A GP review of the pain and of her medicines, with you there or with her agreement to tell you how it went.

  5. What is the point. I am just a burden to everyone.

    May sit underneath

    Low mood or depression

    Constant negativity, poor sleep, aches and losing interest in food can all be signs of depression, which is treatable at any age.

    What tends to help: A GP appointment if it has lasted most days for more than two weeks.

  6. Did you lock the car? Have you paid that bill? You never told me.

    May sit underneath

    Worry, or a change in memory

    Worrying about everything can be anxiety. New worry that comes with forgetting, repeating questions or losing things can be an early sign of memory change.

    What tends to help: A GP appointment, with a written note from you of what you have noticed and since when.

None of this means she is being difficult on purpose, and none of it means you have to give her everything she asks for. It means the most useful answer may not be the one she asked for. Driving over at ten at night meets the request; a fixed evening call and a companion on two afternoons meet the loneliness behind it. Our guides on caring for an elderly parent cover the practical side of the same changes.

Try not to put a label on her. Words like narcissist are easy to find online and hard to use well; only a clinician who has assessed her can say whether there is a condition behind a lifelong pattern, and the limits and the shared-out week below help whatever the cause.

If this is new

If the change is new, ask her GP to look first

How quickly the change arrived tells you a great deal about what to do next.

How quickly did the change come? The faster it came, the sooner someone should see her

  1. She has always been like this

    Years

    The pattern was there long before she got older; age and loneliness have made it louder.

    Set limits and share the load. If pain, low mood or forgetting has arrived on top of the old pattern, that new part is worth a GP appointment.

  2. It has crept up over weeks or months

    Weeks to months

    New negativity, new neediness, new worry or new forgetfulness that you can date to a season, a fall, a bereavement or a move.

    Book a GP appointment. Write down what changed and roughly when, and take it with you.

  3. It changed over hours or a day or two

    Hours to days

    Suddenly confused, agitated, frightened or not herself. An infection such as a urinary infection is a common cause of sudden confusion in older people.

    The NHS says to go to A&E or call 999 if someone suddenly becomes confused.

Sources: NHS pages on confusion, depression and dementia symptoms.

Depression in later life does not always look like sadness. The NHS lists unexplained aches and pains, changes in appetite, disturbed sleep and a lack of energy among its physical symptoms, and says to see a GP if symptoms last most of the day, every day, for more than two weeks. Early dementia can show first as mood changes, or as someone becoming more withdrawn or anxious, and the NHS says to talk to a GP sooner rather than later. If she has always been critical but the worry, the repeated questions or the neediness are new, treat the new part as a health question.

She may not want to go. You can write to the GP or ring the surgery and say what you have seen, even if the GP cannot tell you much back without her agreement. A short note with dates helps: when the calls started, what she says, what has changed with sleep, food and memory. Spotting the signs of depression and anxiety in an older parent explains what the GP is likely to ask and what treatment can look like.

Saying no

What to say when the answer is no

A no is easier to say, and easier for her to hear, when it comes with the next time she will see you.

Long explanations give her something to argue with, and a new reason each time teaches her that the next push might work. A short, warm no, said the same way each time, ends the bargaining sooner. These are starting points; put them into your own words.

  1. She asks you to come round now, and you cannot

    Mum

    Can you come round? I just want some company.

    You

    I cannot come tonight, Mum. I will ring you at six as usual, and I am coming on Sunday for lunch. What would you like to do on Sunday?

    Why it works: A clear no, then the next time she will see you, then a choice for her to make. She leaves the call with something to look forward to.

  2. The guilt trip

    Mum

    After everything I did for you, and you cannot spare an hour.

    You

    I know you did a lot for me, and I am grateful. I still cannot come today. I will be there on Sunday.

    Why it works: You agree with the true part and do not argue the rest. Repeating the same no, calmly, ends the bargaining sooner than a new reason each time.

  3. She treats you like the help

    Mum

    While you are here, do the bathroom, change the bed and ring the gas board.

    You

    I can do the bed today. The bathroom is a job for Tuesday when Sue comes. Shall we ring the gas board together?

    Why it works: You pick the one job you will do, say who does the rest, and keep her doing what she can. The visit stays a visit.

  4. She will not let you go

    Mum

    You have only just got here. Stay for tea.

    You

    I have to leave at four. Let us have a cup of tea now, and I will ring you when I get home.

    Why it works: Say the time you are leaving when you arrive, not at the door. A planned goodbye with a call to follow is easier than a sudden one.

She may push harder at first when you start holding a line. That does not mean it is failing. If the demands turn into shouting or cruelty that is aimed at you, setting boundaries with a parent who is hard to reason with covers what to do when a conversation turns heated.

When she complains

Stopping a complaint going round in circles

Some conversations with a negative parent run the same route every time. Knowing where the circle turns lets you step out of it.

How a complaint goes round, and where to step out of it

The way out, at step 2

  1. a. Name the feeling

    "That sounds lonely." "You sound fed up with it."

  2. b. Offer one thing, once

    "Do you want me to ring the surgery, or shall we leave it?"

  3. c. Change the subject on purpose

    "Tell me what was on the radio this morning."

  4. d. If it keeps going, close kindly

    "I am going to go now. I will ring you tomorrow at six."

The turn happens at step two. When you reassure ("it's not that bad") or fix ("I'll ring the council"), you are answering the complaint, but the complaint was carrying a feeling, and the feeling has not been heard. So it comes back in a new shape. Naming the feeling costs you nothing and does not mean agreeing with her: "that sounds lonely" is true even if the neighbours are perfectly nice.

If she worries about everything, the same approach works for worry. Answer the worry once, plainly, then move to something else. Answering it six times tells her it was worth worrying about. If the worry is constant and stops her doing things, mention it to her GP, because anxiety can be treated at any age.

Set call times

Set call times she can count on

A call she knows is coming at six is worth more to her than three she had to chase.

Pick a time you can keep every day, even on your worst day, and tell her what it is. Ten minutes at six o'clock that never fails is better than an hour when you remember. Once she trusts that the call will come, she has less reason to ring you at work.

Agree what counts as an emergency, write it on a card by her phone, and keep that line open at any hour: a fall, feeling unwell, someone at the door she does not know. For everything else, you can let the call go to voicemail and ring back at the agreed time. If she is ringing many times a day and you are worried about what that means, why an elderly parent keeps calling you goes through the causes and the practical fixes for the phone itself.

Sharing the company

Sharing out the company she needs

One person cannot be all of someone's company. Spread over the week, the same need becomes something you can carry.

The same week, before and after the company is shared out

Now

Every lonely hour turns into a call to you, at any time.

MorningAfternoonEvening
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
Sun

Shared out

She knows who is coming and when. You ring at six every evening.

MorningAfternoonEvening
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
Sun
  • An unplanned call to you
  • You, at a time she knows
  • A paid companion, same person each week
  • A free befriending call or group
  • Nobody

Two companion afternoons of 3 hours come to £90 to £120 a week, at the £15 to £20 an hour that companion carers on PrimeCarers advertise, with our fee included.

The free options come first, and they are worth asking for even if she says she will not like them. Age UK has telephone and face-to-face befriending services, where a volunteer rings or visits for a chat. The Silver Line Helpline, run by Age UK, takes free calls at any hour on 0800 4 70 80 90, so a chat at three in the morning does not have to be with you. Her GP can also refer her to a social prescribing link worker for local groups and lunch clubs.

A paid companion adds what a volunteer may not be able to: the same person, on the days you choose, for as long as you book. On two fixed afternoons they can sit with her over lunch, go for a walk, play cards or sort photographs with her, and be there for the hours she dreads. Because she knows Tuesday and Thursday are covered, those are two afternoons she is not waiting by the phone for you. How a befriender, a volunteer visitor and a paid companion compare sets out what each one costs and how to get it.

If she says no to strangers

When she says she does not want a stranger in the house

She can want company and still refuse a carer. Both are real, and the way you introduce someone makes the difference.

Avoid the word carer if it frightens her. Call it what it is to her: someone to go out with on a Tuesday, help with the garden, a lunch companion. Start small, with one afternoon a week, and be there for the first visit so the new person is introduced by you rather than arriving alone. Let her decide what they do together, which gives back some of the control that the demands were reaching for.

On PrimeCarers you choose the companion yourselves. Carers are self-employed, and you look at their profiles together, meet the ones you like before anyone starts, and agree the days, hours and routine directly with the person you pick. You can keep the same person week after week, which matters to someone who finds new faces hard. Every carer has had their identity and right to work checked, an enhanced DBS check (or PVG in Scotland, Access NI in Northern Ireland) issued within the last 2 years, and an online interview. Carers are insured while they work. We do not check qualifications, training or references, so ask about their experience at the meeting. Companion carers on PrimeCarers advertise £15 to £20 an hour, with our fee included.

When she is ready to meet someone, you can search for companion carers near her and read their profiles with her.

Your own patience

Keeping your own patience

Feeling irritated with a mother you love is ordinary, and it is a sign you need more support, not that you are a bad daughter or son.

Patience runs out fastest when you are tired and nobody else is sharing the load, and when every visit has become a list of jobs. Keep one visit a week for doing something together rather than doing things for her. Tell a brother or sister which day is theirs. Ask the council for a carer's assessment: anyone over 18 who cares for someone can ask, it is free, and it looks at what would help you, separately from anything she is assessed for.

Guilt tends to say that any limit is a failure of love. The limits on this page are what let you keep visiting, keep ringing and keep caring for the years ahead. If you have moved past irritation into something heavier, how to stop feeling resentful as a caregiver is written for that.

Questions

Questions about a demanding elderly mother

A demand in later life can carry a need: company, reassurance, relief from pain, or a say in their own life when other choices have gone. Low mood and early memory change can show up as neediness or criticism too. If the change is new, ask her GP to look; if it is a lifelong pattern that has got louder, limits and more people in her week help most.

Because you are tired, because the relationship has turned round, and because the same conversations repeat. Feeling annoyed does not make you unkind. It is a sign to change the arrangement: shorter, fixed calls, visits that include something you both enjoy, and someone else covering part of the week.

Only a clinician who has assessed her can say whether a personality condition is involved, and labels found online rarely help. What helps is the same either way: clear, repeated limits, not arguing with the guilt, and making sure you are not her only source of company. If the behaviour is new, ask her GP to look for a health cause first.

If she can make the decision for herself, she has the right to say no, and pushing harder usually hardens the no. Offer one small thing, such as a single afternoon out, introduce the person yourself, and come back to it after a few weeks. Holding your own limits still applies, whether or not she accepts help.

Someone she can look forward to seeing

Search carers near your mum who offer companionship, read their profiles, rates and reviews, and meet the ones you like before anything is booked. Free to search.

Free to searchNo obligationID and DBS checkedYou choose the carer