The perfect carer doesn’t exist: what families learn by the third one

By the third carer, most families have stopped hoping for the perfect one. What they want by then is narrower and far more useful: someone who suits the house, who the person actually likes, and who will still be there in six months. Families who call us are often surprised by which of those turns out to be the hard part.

Private Carers – The Definitive Guide (Updated for 2024)

Read Now

The advert lists skills. The decision gets made on temperament.

Almost every care job post starts as a list of tasks: personal care, medication prompts, a hoist, meals, a driver, some light housework. That list matters. But when a family meets three carers who can all do those things, the choice between them is made on something the advert never mentioned. Was the house calmer or busier with that person in it. Did their mother sit up and talk, or go quiet. Did the carer fill every silence.

A daughter arranging care for her mother, who is in her late nineties and bedbound, put it better than we could:

It is not one size fits all. It is the context and the house, not necessarily the patient, that needs managing.

Her mother’s physical needs were, in her words, straightforward. The difficult part was the household: the routines, the family, and how a new person slots into a home that has run a certain way for decades.

Another family learned it the expensive way. A man with dementia, home after a bad fall, needed calm and quiet above all else. The first carer they tried was warm, talkative and cheerful, which a different client would have adored. It went wrong within days, and nobody had done anything wrong. The brief had asked for competence, and competence turned up.

What to put in the brief that almost nobody puts in

The skills half of a job post is easy to write. This is the half that decides whether the arrangement lasts a year or six weeks:

• The noise level of the house. Quiet and orderly, or radio on and grandchildren in and out. Carers differ enormously in what they find comfortable.
• How much conversation is wanted. Some people want a companion who chats all morning. Some want the shopping done and the kitchen left in peace.
• Who the person used to be. Their trade, their hobbies, what they read, what they built, what they followed. This is the most useful line in a brief and it is nearly always missing.
• The routine that cannot move. The order of the morning, the chair, the mug, the time the television goes on.
• Who else lives there. A spouse who is also frail, an adult child at home, pets, and family who visit and will have opinions.
• Where the job ends. What counts as care, what counts as housework, and what is nobody’s job at all.

The third point does more work than families expect. A woman looking for company for her younger brother, who developed dementia in his early sixties, did not ask us for a dementia specialist. She asked for someone who could sit and talk about cars, motorbikes and woodwork, because that is who he was before he stopped working. He had become withdrawn and sometimes sharp with people, and she was clear about why that hurt: “He used to be so calm, so sweet. It is not who he is.” Matching to the old identity rather than the diagnosis is often what turns a visit into a relationship, which is the point of companionship care.

A woman in her late eighties, living alone, briefed us on temperament without using the word. She could manage most things but was getting weak, and what she wanted was someone of roughly her own generation and background: “I am looking for a touch, shall I say, a touch of having a daughter. Just a touch of it.” That brief is far easier to fill well than “help with shopping”.

The last point protects the carer, and so protects you. One carer described a live-in placement that ended after six weeks, with the family criticising her cleaning and telling her she was wasting their money: “There were times when I felt like the maid as opposed to being the carer.” A blurred boundary rarely gets renegotiated. It just ends the placement, so it is worth knowing what carers notice about the families they work for before you write the post.

Checks tell you what someone can do, not who they are

PrimeCarers checks carers’ identity, right to work and DBS documents, and carers complete our onboarding before they can be booked. Those checks are worth having, and they will tell you nothing at all about whether a person will suit your father.

PrimeCarers is an introductory platform and does not provide, manage, supervise or clinically assess care. Clients remain responsible for checking carer documentation, interviewing carers, checking suitability for their specific needs, and agreeing the scope of care directly with the carer.

That is why the meeting carries so much weight. When you interview a carer, spend less time on tasks, which their experience already answers, and more on temperament. Ask what a quiet shift looks like to them, about a client they did not click with and what they did about it, and what they would do on a day when the person will not get up. Then watch the first visit rather than the CV, because a good trial tells you in an hour what a fortnight of messages will not.

Continuity is a promise in both directions

A daughter rang us furious after a third carer in a row left her mother, a woman in her seventies who has a language barrier and no family or friends nearby. Her anger was fair:

It is not normal to keep changing a carer every two months when it is meant to be one stable carer with one solid job. She is lonely. She does not have family here, does not have a circle of friends. So in her loneliness, she holds on to the carers.

Every departure meant rebuilding trust from nothing, and her mother getting attached again.

The other side of that coin is less often said aloud. Self-employed carers choose their work, and they leave for ordinary human reasons: their own health, a family crisis, a move, or a placement that quietly stopped being sustainable. One live-in carer told us she had gone close to three weeks without proper sleep after her client came home from hospital needing attention through the night. What upset her most was not the work: “Sometimes we feel somehow we are not being heard.” A placement that exhausts the carer does not last, however good the carer is.

The commonest pattern is quieter than a resignation. When a rota keeps changing at short notice, carers stop replying. It is rarely a protest: a self-employed carer who loses two shifts in a week has lost that money and cannot fill the gap the day before. Some short-notice change is unavoidable when health fluctuates or someone ends up in hospital, so the fix is to make those changes cost the carer less. Give as much notice as you honestly can, agree in advance what happens for a cancellation inside twenty four hours, including whether you pay for the shift, and always say why. As one of our team puts it to families who have been through several carers: these are human beings, not robots.

Both halves are worth understanding before you are in the middle of it: what happens when a carer cancels, and who carries the risk with an agency, a platform or on your own. An agency can usually send somebody tomorrow, but you get whoever is free. Booking self-employed carers directly gives you choice and continuity, and makes cover your job to plan.

Two or three carers hold better than one

The families who stop churning tend to be the ones who stop looking for a single irreplaceable person. A daughter caring for her mother in her late nineties decided to build a team of two or three, with overlapping days for handover, after their sole long-serving carer began taking more and more control of the household. One person carrying everything is fragile for everybody, the carer included.

It also takes the fear out. A daughter told us how well her father’s current carer was doing, then admitted what she was really thinking: “I have got this thing about the food at the moment. I am thinking, I am going to lose all of that if she goes.” That dread is the real cost of a one-carer arrangement, and families feel it long before anything goes wrong.

A rota of two or three also matches how the work functions, since live-in carers need proper breaks and cover exists whether you plan it or not. Fit has a price, too. One family working through round-the-clock dementia care at home in 2026 compared over £174,000 a year for separate day and night carers with roughly £142,000 for a live-in carer plus a night carer, and chose the more expensive shape: “Avoiding having somebody living in is worth paying a bit extra. It is a massive intrusion on our lives.”

If live-in is what suits you, plan the carer’s living conditions as deliberately as the rota. Getting the home environment right for your carer is one of the cheapest ways to make someone want to stay.

Write down what leaves with them

When a carer goes, the losses that hurt are not on any list: which spoon, which side to approach from, the phrase that gets her out of bed, the fact that he eats if you sit down with him and refuses if you stand. Families rebuild all of it from scratch, three times, and then start writing it down.

Write it down first. A personalised care plan agreed with your carer should carry the household knowledge as well as the practical detail, and it should be updated by whoever is on shift rather than by you from memory. Where you can, arrange one or two overlapping visits when someone new starts, so the handover happens between the carers instead of through you. And if you are worried about medication, safety or something that has changed suddenly, raise it with the GP, district nurse or your social worker rather than settling it in the house.

What to do next

1. Rewrite your brief in two halves: the tasks, then the household. Noise, conversation, routine, old hobbies, who else is there, and where the job ends.
2. Interview for temperament, not tasks, and use a paid trial visit to see the person in the room before you commit to a rota.
3. Plan for two or three carers with overlapping handover days, even if you only need one at a time today.
4. Agree the cancellation rules in writing at the start, on both sides, including notice and what happens for a late change.
5. When you are ready, post a job describing the household as fully as the care, and expect to meet more than one person before you choose.

Related reading

• Meeting a carer: what a good trial looks like, and what a bad one costs
• When a carer cancels: cover, notice, and the month-ahead rule
• What carers notice about the families they work for
• How to build a positive relationship with your private carer